October, 2025 Drink & a Movie: Witch’s Kiss + Starship Troopers

Starship Troopers was released on November 7, 1997. Three days later I turned 16. I don’t remember exactly how long after that it took me to earn my driver’s license, but there couldn’t have been much of a pause, because my friends and I saw it four times during its initial theatrical run. And so it was that this special effects extravaganza about an interstellar war against “the Bugs” became forever linked in my mind to both autumn and my childhood home of Lancaster, Pennsylvania. This month’s drink, the Witch’s Kiss cocktail from [Jim] Meehan’s Bartender Manual, honors that connection to the past through the saffron in Liquore Strega–it’s grown in southeastern PA, believe it or not–and updates it to the present via apple butter that I make with fruit from the tree in our backyard prepared à la Simply Recipes. Here’s what else is in the cocktail:

2 ozs. Cinnamon-infused reposado tequila (Espolòn)
3/4 oz. Lemon juice
1/2 oz. Strega
1/2 tsp. Agave syrup
1/2 tsp. Apple butter

To infuse the tequila, add a four-inch cinnamon stick to a one liter bottle and let stand for twenty-four hours, then remove. Shake all ingredients with ice, then fine-strain into a chilled cocktail glass. Garnish with a lemon twist.

Witch's Kiss in a coupe glass

Per Meehan, “while tequila shines brightest in a summer Margarita, the aged bottlings mix beautifully with fall fruits and vegetables.” The Witch’s Kiss is case in point. The first impression is all apple-cinnamon with a touch of minerality from the Strega, but the Margarita vibes come through loud and clear on the finish: it’s autumn in a glass, but *early* autumn specifically. I’m not going to pretend that the drink has anything more than a purely associational connection to Starship Troopers, so here’s a picture of my Columbia Tristar DVD copy of the movie, which is still going strong after more than 25 years:

Starship Troopers DVD case

It’s also currently streaming on Netflix with a subscription and is available via a number of other platforms for a rental fee.

Starship Troopers begins with its most iconic recurring motif, a series of “Federal Network” newsreel-style vignettes which first implore the viewer to “do their part” and enlist:

Extreme long shot of ranks of soldiers with the words "Join up now!" superimposed on top of them in a gold font

Then celebrate new planetary defenses against “Bug meteors,” which are described in slightly greater depth when “we” use our cursor to answer the question “do you want to know more?” in the affirmative:

A cursor hovers over the word "more," which is highlighted in blue, under an image of an exploding meteor

Before finally “breaking Net” to take us live to our adversary’s home planet of Klendathu, where an invasion is underway:

A fleet of spaceships navigate through an asteroid field in long shot

We cut to a reporter (Greg Travis) on the surface who soon gets ripped in half by a Bug warrior:

Long shot of a reporter in a military uniform being held aloft by a giant insect
The insect cuts the reporter in half
The reporter's torso and legs fly off in different directions

After which a human soldier named Johnny Rico (Casper Van Dien) addresses the camera and tells the person holding it to “get out of here now”:

Extreme close-up of a soldier addressing the camera

Then himself appears to die in combat:

Medium shot of the soldier from the previous image being impaled by a Bug

Static gives way to a title card reading “one year earlier,” which yields in turn to a shot of Johnny in school in Buenos Aires, where a teacher named Rasczak (Michael Ironside) redirects his attention from amorous doodles:

Close-up of Johnny concentrating on a drawing
Close-up of Mr. Rasczak telling him to pay attention
Medium shot of Johnny now looking up at the front of the room

To a lecture summarizing the main points of the History and Moral Philosophy class which is about to conclude in a scene that Todd Berliner argues in his book Hollywood Aesthetic: Pleasure in American Cinema “contains perverse elements that complicate its genre identity and garble its ideological position.” As he explicates further:

The ideological perversity of the scene results from the fact that Rasczak is lecturing his students about the failure of democracy. He says that the present governing state, which separates people into “civilians” and “citizens,” has restored peace after years of strife caused by “social scientists of the 21st century.” He is describing, in short, a fascist utopia, a military state that affords citizenship only to those who serve in the armed forces.

No straightforward ideological proposition can make sense of the classroom scene because genre cues point in two opposing directions–making Rasczak look alternately like a liberal educator or a fascist ideologue.

After the final bell rings, Johnny participates in a federally-funded research study testing for psychic abilities conducted by his best friend Carl (Neil Patrick Harris):

Close-up of Carl putting a finger on his temple and concentrating intently as he looks offscreen
Close-up of Johnny in front of a screen depicting two playing cards, one face down and the other face up
Close-up of an exasperated Carl with his head in his hands after Johnny clearly fails to correctly identified the face down card

Wins the big game with this teammate Dizzy Flores (Dina Meyer), who has a crush on him:

Medium shot of Johnny celebrating his victory in an orange and black uniform with the team name "Tigers" emblazoned across the chest

And goes to the prom with his girlfriend Carmen Ibanez (Denise Richards), an aspiring pilot who responds to him telling her that he, too, has decided to enlist even though it means his wealthy family will disown him by whispering “my father’s not home tonight” in his ear:

Close up of Carmen whispering in Johnny's ear

A long shot of them kissing during the last dance dissolves into a close-up of the flag of the Terran Federation, then the camera tilts down to show Johnny, Carl, and Carmen taking an oath:

Long shot of the flag of the Terran Federation superimposed over a long shot of Johnny and Carmen kissing amidst a sea of dancing students
Continuation of the previous shot: the dancing students have been replaced by rows of youths taking an oath of federal service
Continuation of the previous shot: the camera has come to rest on Johnny, Carl, and Carmen

When a recruiting sergeant (Robert David Hall) with a robotic arm asks for their orders, we learn that Carmen has been assigned to Fleet like she hoped. Carl says he has been selected for Games & Theory aka military intelligence, to which the officer says, “next time we meet, I’ll probably have to salute you!”

Medium shot of a recruiting sergeant using his robotic hand to give Carl, who is offscreen, a piece of paper

However, he reserves his strongest reaction for Johnny. “Good for you!” he exclaims when he finds out what branch Johnny will be going into, gripping his hand. “Mobile Infantry made me the man I am today.” Then he pushes his chair back to reveal that he’s also missing both of his legs.

Close-up of the recruiting sergeant gripping Johnny's arm with both hands
Medium shot of the lower half of the recruiting sergeant's body

Dizzy winds up at the same boot camp as Johnny and helps him earn the coveted title of squad leader by suggesting that they run one of their old football plays in a scene screenwriter Ed Neumeier identifies as an homage to The Dirty Dozen (which also featured war games between a blue team and a red team) on his DVD commentary track with director Paul Verhoeven:

Close-up of Johnny and Dizzy in combat uniforms smiling at each other
Medium long shot of Johnny defeating his red team opponents in a capture the flag game
Long shot of Johnny waving a red flag in an image reminiscent of the famous photograph from the Battle of Iwo Jima

But Carmen dumps him in a video Dear Johnny (!) letter in the very next scene because she has decided to “go career”:

Close-up of Johnny watching a video Carmen: he looks screen right from the left third of the frame and she is facing the camera

Then he is relieved of command of his squad following the death of a team member in a training accident and sentenced to “administrative punishment”:

Extreme long shot of Johnny awaiting his punishment of flogging as his fellow soldiers watch
Close-up of a whip being held by an officer which mostly covers Johnny, who faces away from the camera
Medium shot of Johnny's shirtless back, which is bleeding from where he has been flogged

After which he resolves to quit despite Dizzy telling him that it only proves he doesn’t “have what it takes to be a citizen.” His phone call home to deliver the good (from their perspective) news to his parents (Lenore Kasdorf & Christopher Curry) gets disconnected, though:

Close-up of a console displaying a split screen image of Johnny's parents talking to him via videophone about how it suddenly has gotten dark
Continuation of the previous shot: the call turns to static

Moments later he learns why: Buenos Aires has been destroyed by one of those meteors we heard about earlier and the Federation is going to war.

Map of Buenos Aires with concentric red circles around it and a cigarette burn in the center
Continuation of the previous shot: the map gives way to flames and destruction
Continuation of the previous shot: a title reading "8,764,582 dead" now appears over a screen otherwise completely covered by flames

Johnny’s commanding officer (Dean Norris) looks the other way as his drill instructor Sergeant Zim (Clancy Brown) tears up his letter of resignation:

Medium shot of Johnny standing next to Sgt. Zim, who holds a piece of paper
Close-up of Johnny's commanding officer
Continuation of the previous shot: the commanding officer turns away
Medium shot of Sgt. Zim standing next to Johnny and tearing up his letter of resignation

And following a FedNet sequence featuring a woman giddily clapping her hands and cheering as a group of children “do their part” by stomping on a bunch of presumably innocent insects:

Low-angle medium shot of a group of children intently crushing insects
Close-up of children's feet crushing insects
Medium shot of a woman clapping and cheering

We find ourselves on “Fleet Battle Station Ticonderoga, deep inside the Arachnid Quarantine Zone,” where the men and women of the Federal Armed Services prepare to attack.” This is where we came in, as the fella says. Johnny survives, of course, even though official records list him as killed in action:

Long shot of Johnny floating in green liquid as his injuries are healed
Close-up of Dizzy and Ace Levy (Jake Busey) holding up a piece of paper identifying Johnny as K.I.A. to the side of the tank

And the second half of the film chronicles the completion of his and his former classmates’ transformation from teen magazine idols into something harder and, especially in the case of Carl, who we last see decked out in garb that would clearly identify him as one of the bad guys if this was a World War II movie, verging on sinister.

Medium long shot of Carl wearing a uniform very reminiscent of the Third Reich putting his hand on a "Brain Bug" so that he can read its mind

In a chapter in the book The Literature/Film Reader: Issues of Adaptation, J. P. Telotte contends that a key difference between Starship Troopers the movie and the novel by Robert Heinlein it’s based on is that while the latter “is a first-person narrative told from Johnny Rico’s vantage point, Verhoeven’s film unfolds, not from the perspective of any individual, but rather from the point of view offered by the audiovisual culture itself,” which enables it to “establish a rather different authoritarian voice, and indeed a subtly tyrannical power, one that is the real heart of its satiric vision.” Andrew O’Hehir said something very similar in his remarkably astute contemporaneous review for Sight & Sound, noting that while Heinlein’s “fascist-flavored Utopia” was “a deadly earnest prescription,” in Verhoeven’s hands “it becomes an aesthetic and ideological field of play.” They’re thinking not just about the FedNet sidebars which explicitly reference historical propaganda pieces:

Title card from a FedNet broadcast that reads "Why We Fight."

And are also, as Neumeier explains in his DVD commentary, “meant to evoke CNN coverage of the Gulf War,” but the rest of the film as well. I think it only really works if you sincerely enjoy it on its own merits for the amazingly undated special effects in scenes like the wreck of Carmen’s ship the Rodger Young:

The Rodger Young splits in half

And the attack on Planet P which surely must have been inspired by the movie Zulu:

Bug warriors scramble over top of their fallen comrades corpses to swarm the walls of a base defended by humans
A soldier on the left side of the screen looks out over thousands of Bug attackers

Action sequences like Johnny single-handedly taking out a giant “Tanker” Bug with a grenade:

Long shot of Johnny leaping onto a Tanker Bug
Johnny brandishes a grenade as he hangs onto the Tanker Bug for dear life
Johnny watches from behind a rock as the Tanker Bug explodes
Johnny stands in front of his fallen foe, covered in its blood

And endlessly-quotable lines like a panelist on a Crossfire-like program (Timothy McNeil) declaring, “frankly I find the idea of a bug that thinks offensive”:

And Sergeant Zim answering a question from Johnny’s skeptical fellow trooper Ace Levy (Jake Busey), about the utility of hand-to-hand combat in an age of nuclear weapons by pinning his hand to a wall with an expertly-thrown knife and declaring, “if you disable the enemy’s hand, he cannot push a button!”

I do, obviously, and that’s why, like Jamelle Bouie, I’m able to read it as an artifact “made by the human government of the film to rally the populace in a losing war against the Bugs” (which a footnote in this 2001 journal article by Lene Hansen indicates was supported by the film’s no-longer-extant late-90s website) or, as O’Hehir suggests, a fable from an alternate universe in which Hitler won. I am genuinely moved by Johnny and Dizzy’s surprise when they discover that their new Lieutenant is their old teacher:

Lieutenant Rasczak inspects his troops with his back to the camera
Close-up of Johnny and Dizzy when they see his face
Medium long shot of Lieutenant Rasczak, who now faces the camera, talking to Johnny, Dizzy, and Ace

Johnny’s eulogy for Dizzy after she dies in his arms:

Medium shot of Johnny speaking over Dizzy's flag-covered coffin

And his reaction to hearing his unit described as “Rico’s Roughnecks” for the first time after he assumes command when Rasczak also dies in combat:

Close-up of Johnny in uniform looking simultaneously proud and sad

Because I am moved, I am also disturbed; because I am disturbed, I am on my guard against being manipulated by these same techniques in other contexts.

Telotte notes that for all its deviations from the book it’s adapted from, “the film still follows the Heinlein pattern of youthful education, in large part because, the movie implies, we have all become very much like juveniles in the process of being molded by today’s media culture.” This strikes me as similar to Neumeier’s commentary track observation that “Carl has become like an insect here” when the image above of him placing his hand on the “Brain Bug” Sergeant Zim has captured to read its mind appears on the screen. Early in the film, Carmen pushes back against a teacher’s (Rue McClanahan) statement that insects are superior to us in many ways on the grounds that “humans have created art, mathematics, and interstellar travel.”

Medium shot of the aforementioned teacher

The rebuttal focuses just on the third item on this list, but as O’Hehir points out, “for all the movie’s humans know, there are arachnid poets greater than Milton.” This is where Starship Troopers *really* starts to get interesting for me. While also still in school, Carl refers to his psychic abilities as “a new stage in human evolution,” which reminds me of two of my previous Drink & a Movie selections: Crimes of the Future, which regards such a possibility in a positive light, and Stalker, which is more circumspect. Neumeier means to criticize Carl by comparing him to an insect, but as Ed Howard observes in a 2009 blog post, his director “focuses equally on the casualties of humans and aliens alike” and “keeps subtly reminding his audience that the aliens are not simply expendable cannon fodder,” for instance in this scene where “Verhoeven’s composition deliberately recalls popular representations of the Pearl Harbor attack and of American napalm bombing raids in Vietnam”:

Long shot of bombers strafing a column of Bug warriors
Continuation of the previous shots: the explosions move forward toward the camera
Continuation of the previous shot: Bug limbs fly everywhere as the explosion grows larger

Similarly, although O’Hehir is right that “of course, we’ll root for the human race against a teeming hive of insects,” scenes like this:

Medium shot of Carl with his back to the camera shooting a Bug prisoner through the bars of its cell

And this:

Medium shot of a human shoving a nasty-looking instrument inside one of the Brain Bug's orifices, although the details are covered up by a black bar with the word "Censored" in it in red text

Nonetheless inarguably constitute torturing prisoners of war, and our species’ reaction to Carl’s triumphant announcement that the captured Brain Bug is afraid is also shameful:

Close-up of Carl saying, "it's afraid!"
Long shot of soldiers celebrating

Heinlein obviously intends insect society as a metaphor for America’s Cold War Communist enemies; Neumeier and Verhoeven flip this around and equate the Bugs with fascism. More important than specific ideologies, though, is the universal truth that the harder you try to vilify a supposed enemy, the likelier it is that you will come to embody their “worst” tendencies yourself. Or to quote another movie I saw in high school, 8MM, “if you dance with the devil, the devil don’t change–the devil changes you.”

Cheers!

All original photographs in this post are by Marion Penning, aka My Loving Wife. Links to all of the entries in this series can be found here.

September, 2025 Drink & a Movie: Elotes Sour + The Exterminating Angel

A thought popped into my head awhile back when fresh sweet corn from regions to the south started to appear in local grocery stores: I should make a drink reminiscent of elotes! As J. Kenji López-Alt has written, it is after all “the best way to serve corn, period,” and by enshrining its flavors in a cocktail, I’d be able to enjoy it year-round even when its main ingredient is out of season. So I grabbed a bottle of Finger Lakes Distilling’s Glen Thunder Corn Whiskey out of the pantry, fat-washed it with cotija cheese, mixed it up with some lemon juice to make a sour . . . and went straight back to the drawing board, because the resulting concoction was absolutely terrible. In fact, my first BUNCH of attempts were failures. Among the things I learned from these experiences were that:

  • Finger Lakes Distilling isn’t even making Glen Thunder any more, as I found out when I drove all the way out to one of their tasting rooms to try in vain to refresh the bottle I had just kicked
  • Unless handled with an extremely deft hand, cheese-infused spirits risk making the drink you’re using them in taste, to quote My Loving Wife, “vomitous”
  • You can take corn out of a can, but you can’t take the canned flavor out of that corn pretty much no matter what you do with it

The turning point came when I remembered this Food & Wine article and special ordered a bottle of Nixta Licor de Elote from Ithaca’s Red Feet Wine Market. My pivot to Mellow Corn as a replacement for the Glen Thunder also turned out to be a blessing in disguise when it proved to play much nicer with others, and a few tweaks later I had something that not only tasted the way I wanted to, but also remained distinctive enough from the popular Elote Old-Fashioned I discovered around the same time that I remain comfortable claiming my drink as an original creation. Here’s how you make it:

1 1/2 ozs. Mellow Corn
3/4 oz. Nixta Licor de Elote
1/2 oz. Lime juice
1/2 oz. Ancho Reyes
1 teaspoon 2:1 simple syrup
1 Egg white

Start by rimming a chilled cocktail glass with this mixture (I recommend using a mortal and pestle if you have one) inspired by Trader Joe’s Everything But The Elote seasoning, which you could obviously use as an alternative, but it won’t be nearly as good:

  • 1 Tbsp Grated Parmesan cheese
  • 1/2 tsp Lime zest
  • 1/2 tsp Kosher salt
  • 1/2 tsp Granulated sugar
  • 1/2 tsp Chipotle powder
  • 1/4 tsp Dried cilantro
  • 1/8 tsp Citric acid

Combine all of the cocktail ingredients in a shaker and mix with a immersion blender until frothy. Add ice and shake, then strain into your prepared glass over a large ice cube:

Elotes Sour in a cocktail glass

The egg white is essential for achieving the creamy texture I’m going for, so don’t leave it out! If this ingredient makes you squeamish, please note that we usually err on the side of extreme caution by pasteurizing the eggs using an immersion circulator to hold them at 130 degrees in a water bath for 45 minutes to an hour before separating them, which neutralizes the food safety threat without noticeably impacting them otherwise. Cheese, smoke, and heat are the first things you’ll notice, but corn is definitely present on the swallow and even more so on the finish. The drink starts out on the sour side thanks to the citric acid in the spice mixture on the rim, but once your lips stop tingling the balance of the beverage itself is, if I may say so myself, perfect, ensuring that no ingredient overpowers the other and making this more than a novelty cocktail that’s enjoyable for the first few sips but inevitably overstays its welcome. Which is, of course, a reference to the film I’m pairing it with, The Exterminating Angel. Here’s a picture of my Criterion Collection DVD copy:

The Exterminating Angel DVD case

It’s also currently streaming on the Criterion Channel with a subscription and is available via a number of other platforms for a rental fee.

One of my high school English teachers used to say that the hallmark of great literature was a work possessed of both individuality and universality. I can’t think of many movies that better embody this dual standard than The Exterminating Angel, which is to say that I agree with both Seth Colter Walls, who hailed it as “2009’s most indispensable film” in a Newsweek article published shortly after the release of the DVD pictured above, and Mark Harris, who described it in Film Comment eight years later as a “bleak, caustic vision of rich people presiding over the end of civilization” that “does not seem like a movie behind the times so much as a movie of no particular time.” Noting that an opera adaptation by Thomas Adès was set to debut in just a few months and that a musical version by Stephen Sondheim and David Ives was also in the works, the latter went on to suggest that “it can’t be good news that its time may finally have come,” and I believe that’s right, too, for reasons I hope to make clear anon! The Exterminating Angel opens on a household in a flurry of activity. Mexican aristocrats, Edmundo (Enrique Rambal) and Lucía Nobile (Lucy Gallardo) are hosting a dinner for their wealthy friends after a night at the opera, but something is amiss, as we discover when the doorman Lucas (Pancho Córdova. I think–IMDb says Ángel Merino, but the screenplay published by Onion Press in 1969 credits him as “Waiter,” so I’m ruling in favor of Wikipedia) decides to go for a walk even though it means the loss of his job. “Well, if he didn’t like it here, good riddance,” says the majordomo Julio (Claudio Brook)–“there are many Lucases in the world.”

Be that as it may, he isn’t the last to leave and other strange things are afoot at the Casa Nobile, as these two maids discover when their attempt to flee is temporarily thwarted by the untimely arrival of their employers and their guests not just once:

Long shot of two maids stopping in their tracks at the sight of the Nobiles and the guests arriving
Continuation of the previous shots: the maids turn on their heels
Long shot of the Nobiles and their guests entering the mansion

But, inexplicably, twice:

Medium shot of the maids listening at a door for the Nobiles and their guests to finish going upstairs
Long shot of the maids turning on their heels again
Long shot of the Nobiles and their guests inexplicably arriving for a second time

As they sit down to dinner, the repetitions (which director Luis Buñuel suggests he was the first to use this way in a movie in an interview with José de la Colina and Tomás Pérez Turrent collected in their book Objects of Desire) continue as Edmundo gives the same toast a second time:

Medium shot of Edmundo giving a toast

And the remaining staff follow the maids out the door:

Long shot of two more servants putting on their coats and departing

Lucía also decides to abandon a jest involving a bear and some sheep after her guest Mr. Russell (Lucy Gallardo) responds negatively to one whereby a waiter (Merino) deliberately “trips” while serving the first course:

Close up of a waiter falling face-first toward the camera as food explodes outward from the tray he was cerrying

Finally, matters really take a turn toward the surreal after dinner when the guests would normally leave, but find instead that none of them are able to cross the threshold of the drawing room:

So against every rule of etiquette they settle in for the night:

Medium shot of someone getting ready to sleep in a chair
Medium shot of another guest lying down on the floor
Medium shot of two more people lying down on the floor

When Julio arrives with leftovers for breakfast the following morning, he discovers that he is now trapped as well:

Medium shot of Julio looking up
Medium shot of Julio looking straight ahead to the right with an anguished expression on his face
Medium shot of Lucía looking at Julio as he crumples to the ground

Which brings us to just about exactly 1/3 of the way through the film’s 95-minute runtime. In an interview included with the Criterion DVD as an extra, Silvia Pinal (who plays a guest named Leticia aka “The Valkyrie) quotes a friend of hers as saying that “Buñuel invented reality shows with The Exterminating Angel.” Most of the remaining hour does indeed prove that no one is there to make friends and as the days stretch into weeks the increasingly uncivilized assembly take turns throwing each other under the bus by surreptitiously tossing life-saving medicine where it can’t be reached:

Close-up of hands opening a pill box
Medium shot of a Raul (Tito Junco) looking around to make sure no one is watching him
Raul throws the pill box through the threshold no one can cross

Engaging in sexual abuse under the cover of darkness:

Alberto Roc (Enrique García Álvarez) prepares to grope Rita Ugalde (Patricia Morán)

And threatening to resort to human sacrifice despite the total lack of evidence that it would accomplish anything. They break open a pipe in the wall to find water:

Medium shot of a guest taking an axe to the wall
Close-up of a punctured pipe gushing water

But are reduced to eating paper when the leftovers from dinner run out:

Medium shot of Julio offering Beatriz (Ofelia Montesco) paper to eat

Until the bear from earlier miraculously chases the sheep which were to be part of the same entertainment into the drawing room:

Long shot of a bear climbing the stairs of the mansion
Medium shot of sheep fleeing the bear through the mansion
Medium shot of the sheep in the foreground walking to the drawing room in the background watched by all of the guests, who stand in the threshold

Where they are blindfolded:

The Valkyrie blindfolds one of the sheep as Edmundo prepares to slaughter with a knife

Slaughtered, and cooked over a fire made with wood from a smashed cello:

Long shot of a floor strewn with debris, including a cello at the top of the frame
Continuation of the previous shot: Raul smashes the cello with an axe
Long shot of the guests huddled around a smoky cookfire, framed by the threshold that they can't cross

Bodies nonetheless begin to pile up after Russell expires of natural causes:

Hands cover Mr. Russell's body with a sheet

And two of the trapped guests who are having an affair choose a lovers’ suicide over attempting to go on. Haunted by nightmare images like this disembodied hand:

Long shot of a disembodied hand crawling along the floor through an open door

And let down by rituals such as these kabbalistic “keys”:

Medium shot of Ana (Nadia Haro Oliva) leading two companions in a kabbalistic ritual

The Masonic cry for help:

Christian Ugalde (Luis Beristáin) unsuccessful attempts to summon his fellow Masons

And “the unpronounceable word”:

Medium shot of Christian and Alberto Roc reciting "the unpronouncable world"

A contingent of the remaining guests indicate that they are determined to go through with their plan to kill Edmundo under the reasoning that “when the spider’s dead, the web unravels.” Dr. Carlos Conde (Augusto Benedico) opposes them saying, “but you’re crazy! It’s ridiculous, completely irrational.”

Long shot of Dr. Conde confronting a group of guests who want to kill Edmundo

To which they reply, “we’re not interested in reason: we want to get out of here.” Suddenly, Edmundo appears standing next to Leticia and nobly tells them that “there’s no use fighting something so easily achieved”:

Medium shot of Edmundo standing next to the Valkyrie

He retrieves a revolver from a cabinet but before he is able to turn it on himself Leticia cries out, “wait!” She announces that she has realized that “like pieces on a chessboard, moved thousands of times” they’ve somehow all returned to the very spots they were standing in the night they got trapped.

Close-up of Leticia explaining her discovery to everyone

They fumblingly repeat the things they said then and follow her out the door, freed just as mysteriously as they were imprisoned:

Long shot of the guests emerging from the Nobile's mansion

To Skrikanth Srinivasan, The Exterminating Angel is “the greatest of detective films, since its object is not the discovery of the culprit […] but the discovery of the nature of our human and social condition and its motivations.” He finds the answer in the movie’s two-part structure. The first, which concludes with the scene above, “tells us that man has no escape if he locks himself up in society’s rules, opposed to the imperative rules of nature, which can manifest themselves within society’s rules only in a barbaric and secret form in direct contradiction with the spirit of these social rules.” Where Pinal’s friend sees reality television here, scholar James Ramey finds “a cinematic articulation of what in recent years has been described as a posthumanist attitude towards the human” in his article “Buñuel’s social close-up: An entomological gaze on El ángel exterminador/The Exterminating Angel (1962),” noting that it’s “not unlike an ant colony transferred to a glass casement for entomological observation.”

Part two chronicles the tragedy of said colony’s liberation. As Gilles Deleuze observes in Cinema 1: The Movement-Image, “the [Exterminating] Angel’s guests want to commemorate, that is, to repeat the repetition that has saved them; but in this way they fall back into a repetition which ruins them.” And so we find them congregating together once more, this time for a Te Deum at their local cathedral:

Medium shot panning over the Nobile's guests, including Dr. Conde and Julio
Continuation of the previous shot featuring Edmundo and Lucia
Continuation of the previous shot featuring Raul and Ana

As the service ends, the priests stop at the door. “Why don’t we wait until after the faithful have left?” one of them says.

Medium shot of the three priests stopped at the door to the cathedral

The film ends with a plague flag over the cathedral:

Close-up of a plague flag

Violence on the adjacent town square:

Long shot of armed police or military officials attacking a crowd

And another group of sheep offering themselves up as food for the incarcerated:

Long shot of a flock of sheep making its way to the doors of the cathedral

Per Srinivasan, “the elliptical brutality of the last section and the speed with which we arrive at the renewal of the phenomenon of avolition gives us the impression that it’s going to return with ten or twenty times the force,” which echoes something Buñuel himself says in Objects of Desire and reminds me of the ending to The Happening: “the church will be worse because this time it’s not just twenty people, but two hundred. It’s like an epidemic that extends outwards to infinity.” For Srinivasan the cause of all this is clearly religion, but Wael Khairy found that it echoed something even more immediate in a piece for RogerEbert.com published on April 6, 2020:

Much like COVID-19, an invisible force prevents the visitors from stepping outside the confines of the house. The title suggests that this is the work of an exterminating angel. I would never liken an infectious disease to an angel, but one can’t help but dwell on the eerie similarities of how this invisible force is affecting society as a whole. Like “The Exterminating Angel,” this outbreak feels like a wake-up call. Mother Nature is stepping in and exposing fragility of society and how easily the facade we’ve built around us can collapse. 

He concludes by wondering, “What will happen after this global nightmare comes to an end, and millions of families exit their homes? Will we emerge from our homes as changed people with a new awareness of the world, or will we fall back into the same trap?” Sadly, five years later, I think we all know what the answer to this question is. But, hey, when the end comes, at least now you have a new drink to toast it with, right?

Cheers!

All original photographs in this post are by Marion Penning, aka My Loving Wife. Links to all of the entries in this series can be found here.

Juxtaposition #11

From Burial Path:

Close-up of the silhouette of a dead bird

From “I Saw Another Bird” by Mount Eerie:

I can’t remember having crossed a threshold
Between the dust and the alive
So when a raven starts a convеrsation
I just stand there and blank out

But I’m wrong!

Therе is another world inside this one
It shines:

These birds trying for my attention
And my wordless reply

Previous “Juxtaposition” posts can be found here.

Ithaca Film Journal: 8/28/25

What I’m Seeing This Week: I didn’t make it to Relay at Cinemapolis last week, so it remains first up on my list. I’m hoping to see Caught Stealing there or at the Regal Ithaca Mall as well.

Also in Theaters: In addition to the titles above, I’m also going to try to catch Honey Don’t! at Cinemapolis and The Roses there or at the Regal before they close. The best new movie now playing Ithaca that I’ve already seen remains Highest 2 Lowest, which continues its run at Cinemapolis. I also enjoyed Weapons, which is there and at the Regal; The Fantastic Four: First Steps, The Naked Gun, and Superman, all of which are just at the Regal; and Sorry, Baby, which plays Cornell Cinema (welcome back!) on Friday. Local screenings of 35mm films are sadly become quite rare, so the presentation of a new restoration print of Donnie Darko at Cornell Cinema on Saturday definitely qualifies as a “special events” highlight! Finally, your best bets for repertory fare are the 50th anniversary screenings of Jaws at Cinemapolis and the Regal all week, It Happened One Night at Cornell Cinema on Sunday, and The Dark Knight at the Regal on Tuesday.

Home Video: If you are drafting a fantasy football team this weekend, consider unwinding afterward the way we did with The Dirty Dozen, which is available on Watch TCM until September 15! I had completely forgotten that I briefly broke down this Last Supper reference back in 2006 until we got to it:

Long shot of the "dirty dozen" sitting at a long table reminiscent of many paintings of the last supper

But was glad to be reminded, because although I question my overreliance on reading this as a nod to the mural by Leonardo da Vinci specifically, I think it still contains some good thoughts. First off, the original screengrab is lost to time, but I believe this must be the “joke” I refer to:

Medium shot of the dinner being immortalized in a photograph

The bit about Telly Savalas’s Maggot not being in the position of Judas is nonsense, but I do like my suggestion that the overhead shots may represent the filmmakers inserting themselves into the scene, especially in the context of an observation in one of My Loving Wife’s old art history textbooks about Tintoretto’s Last Supper, which like Robert Aldrich’s sets the table at a diagonal, that it “used two internal light sources: one real, the other supernatural.” I wonder if this is meant to make us conscious of the presence of studio lights:

Overhead shot of Lee Marvin's Major John Reisman addressing his men

I could write a whole post on the results-oriented leadership style of Lee Marvin’s Major John Reisman in the face of orders from a “someone up there” (another possible reading of the previous image) who is “a raving lunatic,” but it might get me in trouble at work if misinterpreted, so instead I’ll note that the film’s position on capital punishment echoes those of the texts I wrote about in my July, 2025 Drink & a Movie blog post. And, right: football! The connection there is of course running back-cum-actor Jim Brown’s dramatic death scene at the end a heroic first down-length dash through enemy gunfire:

Medium shot of Jefferson preparing to blow up the Nazi officers it is the dozen's mission to assassinate
Long shot of Jefferson being gunned down
Medium shot of Jefferson's lifeless body

I concede that I may have overstated my case a tiny bit by calling it “the rare World War II film not afraid to acknowledge the sins that we the victors conveniently leave out of most of the rest of our official histories” on Letterboxd, considering that it’s obviously really about Vietnam, but this absolutely is still one of my favorite examples of that genre.

Previous “Ithaca Film Journal” posts can be found here. A running list of all of my “Home Video” recommendations can be found here.

August, 2025 Drink & a Movie: Shady Lane + Tokyo Drifter

We planted red shiso in our herb garden a couple of years ago as a novelty. It unexpectedly came back the following spring and basically took over, which we soon discovered poses a bit of a challenge because it has such a distinctive color and flavor that most recipes you find it in use only a small quantity, so it’s hard to dispatch in bulk. Luckily, although it still pops up all over our yard, the amount competing for space with other edible plants is now more or less under control and it has returned to being a valued occasional guest on our summer meal plans in dishes like Marc Matsumoto’s twist on capellini pomodoro and as one of the “fresh tender herbs” in our house salad dressing, Food & Wine magazine’s whole lemon vinaigrette.

Shiso plant growing wild in middle of our yard

Like the mint we also grow, though, the place it really shines is a drink component and garnish. Our favorite such beverage is the Shady Lane from Brad Thomas Parsons’ Bitters book, which has long been part of our home mixology library but somehow hasn’t yet made an appearance on this blog. Here’s how to make it:

1 1/2 ozs. Gin (Roku)
3/4 oz. Lillet Rouge
1/2 oz. Blackberry-lime syrup
1/2 oz. Lime juice
2 dashes Scrappy’s Lime bitters
3 Blackberries, plus more for a garnish
3 Shiso leaves, plus more for a garnish
Club soda

Make the blackberry-lime syrup by combining one cup of blackberries with one cup each of sugar and water and the zest of two limes and bring to a simmer, stirring occasionally and mashing the berries with a wooden spoon. Remove from heat, cool completely, and strain, reserving the solids. To make the cocktail, muddle the blackberries and shiso leaves in the bottom of a shaker with the syrup. Add ice and all of the other ingredients except the club soda and shake, then strain into a chilled rocks glass. Top with club soda and garnish with additional blackberries and a shiso leaf.

Shady Lane in a rocks glass

First off, despite what Parsons says, DO NOT DISCARD THE SOLIDS AFTER MAKING THE SYRUP: hey are absolutely delicious with yogurt and granola! Shiso is a difficult flavor to describe to people not already familiar with it. Writing for the New York Times in 1995, Mark Bittman went with “it has a mysterious, bright taste that reminds people of mint, basil, tarragon, cilantro, cinnamon, anise or the smell of a mountain meadow after a rainstorm,” which, sure, I guess, but the quote by Jean-Georges Vongerichten four paragraphs later also gets the job done: “I like it a lot.” Whichever way you want it, that’s what dominates the first sip of a Shady Lane, but this immediately slides gracefully into dark fruit, lime zest, and juniper. The drink’s balance is absolutely perfect–it doesn’t register as particularly sweet or tart–and the effervescence from the club soda and spiciness of the Japanese gin make it a great summer sipper. Parsons explains that he named this concoction after the classic Pavement song, so it would be a great choice to pair with the film about them that recently debuted on Mubi, but its brilliant purple hue reminded me of the garish colors of Tokyo Drifter, so that’s what we’re going with. Here’s a picture of my Criterion Collection DVD copy:

Tokyo Drifter DVD case

It’s also currently streaming on the Criterion Channel with a subscription and available via a number of other platforms for a rental fee.

As Tom Vick writes in his book Time and Place are Nonsense: The Films of Seijun Suzuki, “Tokyo Drifter begins with a gesture more at home in experimental than commercial cinema: grainy, high-contrast, black-and-white opening scenes that were shot on expired film stock.” A man wearing a light-colored suit with white shoes and gloves walks toward the camera along a railroad track:

Tokyo Drifter's opening shot

He is “Phoenix” Tetsu (Tetsuya Watari) and until recently none dared mess with him or his yakuza boss Kurata (Ryûji Kita). They’ve gone straight, though, and Kurata’s rival Otsuka (Eimei Esumi) has decided to test Tetsu’s resolve by ambushing him:

Two men hold Tetsu in the center of the frame while a third winds up to punch him and a fourth man watches from the left of the frame
Continuation of the previous shot: Tetsu reels from the blow

Otsuka watches from a nearby car:

Extreme close-up of Otsuka wearing sunglasses

And predicts that Tetsu will “get knocked down three times, then rise up like a hurricane” in a voiceover that accompanies the brief color fantasy sequence that Criterion chose as the basis for their cover art:

A pink light flashes as Tetsu, clad in a yellow sports coat, shoots his gun at something offscreen facing left against a black background
Tetsu faces right as he crouches and aims his gun
Tetsu dives to the ground and rolls while aiming his gun at a gray-suited figure in the foreground

But when Tetsu stubbornly refuses to fight back he says, “I see. So we can do anything we want.” The sequence ends with another splash of color when Tetsu, having staggered to his feet after his beating, looks down and spies a broken gun which is obviously a prop and glows red against a monochrome background:

Overhead close-up of a red gun lying in pieces on a railroad tie next to Tetsu's shoe

Which Peter Yacavone contends “promotes a consciousness of cliché” in his book Negative, Nonsensical, and Non-Conformist: The Films of Suzuki Seijun. Whatever Otsuka wants turns out to be stealing a building from Kurata by forcing his business partner Yoshii (Michio Hino) to sign a sizeable debt over to him at gunpoint:

Close up of a hand holding a gun balanced on a stack of money in front of contracts and a deck of cards

Then shooting him:

Otsuka, out of focus in the left foreground, points a gun at Yoshii, who is opening a door in the right third of the frame

Tetsu arrives moments too late to help:

Tetsu opens a door and Yoshii's body falls out on the right side of the frame; the left is dominated by a purple wall

And is knocked out in the skirmish that follows:

Overhead shot of Tetsu lying unconscious at the bottom of an elevator shaft in the middle of the frame

He revives in time to save Kurata from signing over the building to Otsuka:

Medium shot of Tetsu smiling as he holds a gun

But not before Kurata accidentally kills Yoshii’s secretary Mutsuko (Tomoko Hamakawa) while trying to shoot Otsuka:

Close up of a drop of blood dribbling down Mutsuko's breast as she lies on the ground in front of a red background

Tetsu confronts Otsuka’s henchman Tatsu “the Viper” (Tamio Kawachi) in a junkyard sequence that includes a largely gratuitous depiction of a car being demolished:

Medium shot of a car in front of an incinerator
Continuation of the previous shot: the car is now burning
The car, which is now burnt, being dumped out onto the ground

As well as Tetsu singing the movie’s insanely catchy titular theme song:

Medium shot of Tetsu in a blue suit singing in the middle of the frame

Tetsu informs Tatsu that he intends to take the rap for Mutsuko’s murder should Otsuka attempt to finger his boss, and that if he is arrested he’ll let the police know who killed Yoshii. Otsuka responds by sending an emissary to Kurata to propose a trade: if he hands over Tetsu, they’ll return the deed to his building. He refuses:

Medium shot of Kurata in front of a lime green background

And moved by his gesture, Tetsu, who overheard the conversation, decides to leave town:

Medium shot of Tetsu in front of a lime green background

Tony Rayns, writing in the book Branded to Thrill: The Delirious Cinema of Suzuki Seijun, argues that “the ultimate fascination of Tokyo Drifter is that despite the apparently wilful ‘deconstruction’ of the genre, it none the less works as a thriller.” One great example of both parts of this proposition is a duel fought in front of a train speeding down on the combatants shortly after Tetsu arrives in Shonai, home of one of Kurata’s allies, with Otsuka’s men hot on his heels. When they attack he signals his presence by again singing the film’s theme song as he walks through the snow:

Long shot of Tetsu walking through a snowy landscape singing
Medium shot of Tetsu in a snow flurry, still singing

Then joins the fray. As he takes cover behind some bales of hay, voiceover narration signals his thoughts: “my range is under ten yards.”

Close-up of Tetsu crouching behind a bale of hay

Suddenly, he spots a pair of geta in a shaky cam POV shot:

Blurry POV shot from Tetsu's perspective, indicating that the camera is in motion
Continuation of the previous shot: a pair of geta have appeared in the bottom-left corner of the frame
Close-up of the geta

The idea, of course, is that they are ten yards away from Tetsu’s enemies, which explains why he leaps toward them moments later:

Long shot of Tetsu lying on the ground on the right side of the frame firing his gun toward the camera next to the geta from the previous image, which occupy the left side of the frame

Fast forward to the next scene. It begins with Tetsu trudging through a field covered in snow, which cinematographer Shigeyoshi Mine and production designer Takeo Kimura identify as the movie’s true protagonist in a delightful anecdote about an alcohol-fueled creative session by director Seijun Suzuki that I’m grateful to Vick for including in Time and Place are Nonsense:

Kimura has confidence in Mine’s talent, with whom he is able to create an image like a sumi-e [a traditional ink-wash painting]. But the characters of the two men do not harmonize well. Mine is impulsive, Kimura is complex. One trait they have in common is that they are both egotists. … When they are drinking sake, their ego emerges with greater force. …They discuss the photography of [Tokyo Drifter], in which the snow is the protagonist of the story. I’m being canny. I wait until they stop arguing. Sometimes they turn to me, but I don’t respond, because for me it is enough to decide at the time when the camera has to be set up. The snow already has provoked something in these men, whichever image of the snow will eventually transpire.

Anyway, as Tetsu walks he realizes he’s being followed:

Long shot of Tetsu standing in the middle of a snowy field looking at the camera

No explanation is offered for either the way he vanishes from his pursuer Tatsu’s sight in between shots or the apparently nondiegetic triangular shadow that appears at the same time:

Medium shot of Tatsu checking his gun
POV shot from Tatu's point of view of the now-empty field where Tetsu just was with the top left corner of the frame covered by a translucent shadow

But the next thing we know Tetsu has gone from prey to predator and awaits Tatsu under a bridge:

Close-up of Tetsu hiding behind a concrete pillar
Extreme long shot of Tatsu crossing a bridge while Tetsu watches him from below

There’s a close-up of Tatsu standing in front of a railway signal:

Close-up of Tatsu standing in front of a railway signal and pyramidal shadow over a white background

Followed by one of a train:

Close-up of a train

And suddenly the Viper is aiming his gun at the Phoenix:

Long shot of Tetsu in the foreground with his back to camera facing off against Tatsu, who aims a gun at him in the middleground

In quick succession there’s a close-up of Tatsu, followed by one of Tetsu, followed by a shot of a steam engine’s boiler:

Close-up of Tatsu pointing his gun offscreen to the right
Close-up of Tetus looking offscreen to his left
Close-up of a steam engine's boiler

Still Tatsu waits:

Another long shot of Tatsu standing with his back to the camera in the foreground holding a gun on Tetsu in the background; there's now a train approaching him from behind

As the train continues to draw closer to Tetsu, Suzuki switches to wonderfully artificial-looking back projection:

Close-up of Tetsu in front of a back-projected train

Cut to a POV shot from Tetsu’s perspective as he counts railway ties: “15 yards, 14, 13, 12 . . . 10.” The end of the list is marked by a red line in the snow defining what we learned earlier is the limit of his range:

As Tetsu makes his move, Tatsu finally starts to fire:

Long shot of Tatsu firing his gun toward the camera in a POV shot from Tetsu's perspective

Tetsu runs toward him and dives to the ground, shooting back:

Extreme long shot of Tetsu running toward the red line mentioned above in front of a train
Tetsu dives to the ground as he reaches the line in a continuation of the previous shot
Tetsu's gun flashes orange in a continuation of ther previous shot

Cut first to close-up of the train, then to a long shot of Tetsu walking away, apparently having won:

Yacavone writes that this all “plays like deliberately orchestrated nonsense,” but also concedes that it’s “exciting on its own terms,” which I think is basically the same thing Rayns is saying and goes double for Tokyo Drifter‘s highly-stylized climactic shootout. It follows Kurata betraying Tetsu in the scene that most directly inspired this month’s drink photo:

Kurata and Otsuka who occupy the left and right ends of the frame respectively, sit across from each other in a room with purple walls; two other men occupy the middle of the frame, one in the foreground with his back to the camera and one in the background mostly covered up by him

And features the latter first taking cover behind a slim column:

Tetsu hides behind a column on the right side of the frame as one of Otsuka's henchmen shoots at him from behind another column on the left side of the frame

Then throwing his gun into the air, catching it, and shooting the man who sold him out in one smooth motion:

Medium shot of Tetsu throwing his gun into the air in the middle of the frame
Close-up of Kurata looking offscreen up and to the left
Close-up of a gun suspended in mid-air
Long shot of Tetsu catching his fun and firing it at Kurata from the background in the left third of the frame as the latter grabs his chest in the right foreground

I appreciate Yacavone’s writing on this film because he draws attention to details I suspect I might have missed otherwise, such as the absence of any “visual trace of prewar central Tokyo” from the title sequence featuring a montage of tourist attractions built in preparation for the 1964 Summer Olympics:

Shot of the Tokyo Tower at sunrise
Shot of the Yoyogi Olympic gymnasium
Shot of the San-ai building at night

The way it “exploits the recessed paneling of Tokugawa architecture to suggest an infinite depth that is equated with tradition” and “suggest that in its own way Yamagata, reminiscent of an age of duty, aristocracy, and self-sacrifice, is just as deathly and alienating as Tokyo”:

Deep focus long shot composition featuring Tetsu on the left side of kneeling on a tatami mat on the left side of the frame in front of his host who does the same on the right

Or even just the simple fact that Hideaki Nitani’s character Shooting Star has the same initials as Suzuki.

Exterior long shot of Shooting Star standing in the snow in the center of the frame with his back to the camera

But the overall contours of Tetsu’s journey are easily discernible even to the uninitiated through universal devices like a low-angle shot of a tree in front of a darkening sky that charts his withering loyalty to Kurata:

Shot of a tree in front of a blue sky
Shot of the same tree in front of a gray sky
Shot of the same tree in front of a black night sky

And when the final showdown ends with Tetsu rejecting the woman who loves him (Chieko Matsubara) on the grounds that he “can’t walk with a woman at [his] side” and exiting through a vaginal hallway, we understand that he has been reborn into the world as a truly independent Tokyo drifter:

Medium shot of Tetsu on the right side of the frame in an all-white room walking away from Chiharu in the middle of the frame in front of a marble statue holding a doughnut-shaped object lit in yellow
Long shot of Tetsu walking away from the camera in the middle of the frame down a narrow pentagonal hallway

Which strikes me as representing a level of meta complexity worthy of Pavement’s immortal lyrics “you’ve been chosen as an extra in the movie adaptation of the sequel to your life.”

Cheers!

All original photographs in this post are by Marion Penning, aka My Loving Wife. Links to all of the entries in this series can be found here.