Juxtaposition #33

From Yeelen:

Close-up of the sunrise that Yeelen begins with, even though context retroactively suggests that it takes place AFTER the events depicted in the film

From Idylls of the King by Alfred, Lord Tennyson:

Thereat once more he moved about, and clomb
Ev’n to the highest he could climb, and saw,
Straining his eyes beneath an arch of hand,
Or thought he saw, the speck that bare the King,
Down that long water opening on the deep
Somewhere far off, pass on and on, and go
From less to less and vanish into light.
And the new sun rose bringing the new year.

Previous “Juxtaposition” posts can be found here.

A Canticle for Dr. Kelson

Like the previous director/screenwriter collaboration between Danny Boyle and Alex Garland, 28 Years Later ends with an abrupt tonal shift, and just as Sunshine‘s Pinbacker plotline makes me think of the music video for The Prodigy’s “Firestarter,” the more recent film immediately put me in mind of another turn-of-the-millennium alternative touchstone. But whereas in “Jesus of Suburbia” the protagonist of Green Day’s magnum opus American Idiot “read the graffiti in the bathroom stall, like the holy scriptures of the shopping mall,” the first encounters Alfie Williams’s Spike has with his St. Jimmy are far more sinister:

Medium close-up of a hooded body hanging upside down with the name "Jimmy" carved into its back
Long shot of Spike and his mother walking in front of a stone building that has the words "Behold He Is Coming With the Clouds" written on its wall in large white letters and the name "Jimmy" appended to the message in different handwriting

Which makes sense considering that Jack O’Connell’s Sir Lord Jimmy Crystal is no mere devil on the shoulder like Green Day’s creation, but instead fancies himself the actual Antichrist:

Close-up of an upside down cross pendant
Close-up of Sir Lord Jimmy Crystal wearing the pendant from the previous image

Spike’s journey through the first 28 Years Later movie and its sequel The Bone Temple contains many other echoes of American Idiot: “Holiday / Boulevard of Broken Dreams” starts with rain “comin’ down like an Armageddon flame,” “Give Me Novacaine / She’s a Rebel” describes the relationship between Dr. Ian Kelson (Ralph Fiennes) and Samson (Chi Lewis-Parry) perfectly, and “Extraordinary Girl / Letterbomb” anticipates the conclusion of a trilogy we sadly may never get by asking, “where will all the martyrs go when the virus cures itself?” Furthermore, while there’s no perfect analog for the album’s split personality subplot, Whatsername character, or St. Jimmy’s figurative suicide in “Homecoming,” the war for Spike’s soul that Kelson wages with Crystal serves much the same function.

I admit that you have to squint a bit to see all this, but the movies resonate even more clearly with one of my favorite books, A Canticle for Leibowitz by Walter M. Miller, Jr. Both narratives are set in motion by an apocalypse, and while Leibowitz differs from 28 Years Later in that we don’t open on its nuclear holocaust, the latter’s title card ushers us into a world very similar to the one presented in the novel’s opening line, which Cass Sunstein described as “amazing” last March in this Substack post about it: “Brother Francis Gerard of Utah might never have discovered the blessed documents, had it not been for the pilgrim with girded loins who appeared during that young novice’s Lenten fast in the desert.”

Sunstein also applauds the next line, which I think provides an even better sense of the book’s spirit: “Never before had Brother Francis actually seen a pilgrim with girded loins, but that this one was the bona fide article he was convinced as soon as he had recovered from the spine-chilling effect of the pilgrim’s advent on the far horizon, as a wiggling iota of black caught in a shimmering haze of heat.”

Which evokes this landscape shot:

Extreme long shot of three figures dwarfed by the cloud shadow moving across the rolling hills around them

And the exchange which follows it between Spike and a shipwrecked Swedish soldier (Edvin Ryding) about the “Alphas” who have emerged as the leaders of the de facto tribes that many of the “infected” who haunt the British mainland have organized themselves into:

ERIK: Why do they get so huge? The bärsärk?

SPIKE: Well, Sam says on some the infection kinda works like steroids.

ERIK: Yeah?

SPIKE: I mean, I don’t know what steroids are, but I’m guessing that’s what turns them Alpha.

Like Brother Francis, who believes “Fallout” is the name of an actual demon which he visualizes as “half-salamander, because, according to tradition, the thing was born in the Flame Deluge,” Spike has grown up speaking a language that contains countless words for things completely alien to him. Sunstein’s interest in Leibowitz is grounded in the order of monks that Brother Francis belongs to, whose mission is to preserve as many remnants of a lost civilization, which they call Memorabilia, as possible. The reason Sunstein feels an affinity for them reminds me quite a bit of my own purpose in maintaining this blog:

In North America and Europe, a lot of people (particularly academics, I think) see themselves a bit like Miller’s monks did: as socially marginal, perhaps, but as maintaining certain documents and truths, or perhaps as moving identifiable projects forward, even if there is not a lot of interest in those projects. I speculate that some philosophers and some literature professors see themselves in that way; so, I speculate, do some historians.

They might have substantive ideas. They might focus on certain historical figures. They might prize certain methods. They might care about genres. They might focus on events, periods, and documents to which no one seems to be paying attention.

One of the many haunting features of Miller’s great book is that it casts light on why many people, engaged in work that is now widely ignored, are intensely committed to that work, and have high hopes for its future.

It also reminds me of Dr. Kelson, architect of the second 28 Years Later film’s titular bone temple.

Low-angle shot of Dr. Kelson, Spike, and Spike's mother Isla (Jodie Comer) looking up at a tower of skulls flanked on all sides by pillars of bone

When Spike asks what it is, Kelson replies:

KELSON: I’ve been waiting almost 30 years for someone to ask that question. I often thought I would die here alone . . . of age or starvation or violence . . . never having had the chance to reply. Do you know the words “memento mori”?

SPIKE: No.

KELSON: It’s Latin. Ironically, it’s a dead language. (LAUGHS) It means “remember death.”

The Bone Temple deepens Dr. Kelson’s connection to Brother Francis and his fellow monks by introducing him straining to remember the lyrics to Duran Duran’s “Girls on Film” as he drags an addition to the temple to its new home:

Close-up of Dr. Kelson in front of a vine-covered train car, wearing a vest festooned with poison darts
Medium long shot of Dr. Kelson from behind walking across the frame from left to right, dragging a body covered in a blue tarp behind him
Continuation of the previous image: we now see Kelson from the front, centered in the frame

He is revealed to be a keeper of classical learning as well as pop culture in the next scene when he says to Samson, whom he has drugged, “I named you for your size and strength and hair […] although right now I feel more like Androcles removing thorns from the lion’s paw.”

Close-up of Kelson removing an arrow from Samson's chest

This is followed in due time by a trip to the bunker beneath the temple where Kelson sleeps, which resembles what I imagine the scriptorium of Brother Francis’s abbey might have looked like:

Fisheye lens long shot of Kelson's candlelit bunker

Especially when we’re invited back inside about 40 minutes later as Kelson pursues a hunch about the nature of the Rage Virus:

Close-up of a row of medical books
Close-up of Kelson writing in one book while consulting another
Close-up of a bespectacled Kelson reaching for a volume on the bookshelf in front of him
Close-up of sheets of paper covered in handwritten notes and diagrams

Other moments echo the first part of Leibowitz, “Fiat Homo,” which is set 600 years after the Flame Deluge: the bows Spike and his father (Aaron Taylor-Johnson) use to protect themselves are reminiscent of the arrow that ultimately kills Brother Francis, for instance, and Samson’s favorite snack echoes the cry of “Eat! Eat! Eat!” that accompanies his fall:

Medium close-up of Samson eating brains out of a decapitated skull

Meanwhile, the way Samson’s killing of a deer in the first 28 Years Later is depicted as being almost like a ritual:

Nighttime close-up of Samson's hands twisting a deer's head shot with a red filter
Continuation of the previous image: the infected who follow Samson look on as he holds up the deer's head in the right foreground, the light reflecting eerily off their eyes
Continuation of the previous image: medium close-up of the infected who follow Samson feasting on the body of the deer he killed
Continuation of the previous image: Samson reaches up and impales the head of the deer he killed on a tree branch

And the red light the scene is bathed in made me think of the fireside passage in Part II of Leibowitz, “Fiat Lux,” in which Thon Taddeo Pfardentrott asks “Mad Bear” Hongan Os, chief of the Plains nomads, why his people drink no water:

“Who knows what the gods drink?” mumbled Mad Bear. “It is said that water is for cattle and farmers, that milk is for children and blood for men. Should it be otherwise?”

The insane one was not insulted. He studied the chief for a moment with searching gray eyes, then nodded at one of his fellows. “That ‘water for the cattle’ explains it,” he said. “The everlasting drought out here. A herdsman people would conserve what little water there is for the animals. I was wondering if they backed it by a religious taboo.”

The most important connection is to Part III, “Fiat Voluntas Tua,” though, which is set 1800 years after the Flame Deluge when the nations of earth have inexplicably (considering they know from experience exactly what will happen) brought themselves once more to the brink of nuclear war. Michael Alan Bennett argues in an article for The English Journal called “The Theme of Responsibility in Miller’s ‘A Canticle for Leibowitz'” that the book’s major theme “concerns the question of individual responsibility,” and that “Miller’s conclusion is that if nuclear holocaust occurs, the fault will lie with each individual who did nothing to prevent it.” This plays out most directly in the final chapters in the form of a debate between Abbot Jethrah Zerchi and Doctor Cors, a medic with the Green Star Relief Station where “hopeless cases” are encouraged to go to be put out of their misery. “It’s certainly better than letting them die horribly, by degrees,” argues Cors, to which Zerchi replies:

Is it? Better for whom? The street cleaners? Better to have your living corpses walk to a central disposal station while they can still walk? Less public spectacle? Less horror lying around? Less disorder? A few million corpses lying around might start a rebellion against those responsible. That’s what you and the government mean by better, isn’t it.

“The doctor is innocent of this charge,” is Bennett’s verdict, “but the government is not.” By the same logic, Dr. Kelson is absolved of administering a shot to Spike’s mother Isla (Jodie Comer), who is dying of cancer: as Cors defends his work to Zerchi, “what I meant by better was ‘more merciful.'” Meanwhile, Abbot Zerchi is obviously in no way directly responsible for the world ending a second time the same way as the first, but Bennett argues that Miller does consider him indirectly responsible:

As a monk, isolated in his monastery from the concerns of the world, he is symbolic of all those who are unconcerned, those who drop out, those who despair. Thus, A Canticle for Leibowitz is a novel of and for our time. In an age when the individual man feels ever further removed from the decisions of government which affect us all, Canticle reaffirms an old value. Says Miller: “I am my brother’s keeper!”

Dr. Kelson, whom I called an “orange-skinned anti-Trump” earlier this year on Letterboxd, starts off 28 Years Later like Zerchi, set off from the chaos around him by his bunker, a moat, and the iodine “prophylactic” he paints himself with to hold the Rage Virus at bay. When Sir Lord Jimmy Crystal shows up at the end of The Bone Temple, he is tempted to make the same deal with the devil as Thon Taddeo. Per Bennett, when that “well-meaning but hypocritical scientist” is confronted by evil, he “merely closes his eyes.” Kelson does him one better by dressing up as Old Nick to lend credence to Crystal’s claim that he has an unholy mandate to continue his “infernal mission”:

Low-angle medium close-up of Dr. Kelson disguised as Satan and dancing to the song "The Number of the Beast" by Iron Maiden in the bone temple, which is lit by torches

But he finds his courage when he realizes that Spike has been impressed into Crystal’s gang and adds one more command even though he knows it will likely spell his doom. “I require a sacrifice,” he says:

Medium close-up of Dr. Kelson holding Sir Lord Jimmy Crystal's head as he speaks to him in front of the torchlit Bone Temple

“You know that in order for God’s only son to ascend and take his place by his father’s side, Christ was first required to be crucified,” he tells Crystal. “You are my only son, Jimmy, Jimmy, Jimmy. I am your God. I require the same.” This unsurprisingly gets him a knife in the belly:

Medium close-up of Sir Lord Jimmy Crystal stabbing Dr. Kelson as he stands in front of his tower of skulls, a line of fire behind them

But the damage has already been done, and Crystal meets the same fate as the poor soul whose flesh he scrawled his name into in the previous film:

Long shot of Sir Lord Jimmy Crystal hanging upside down from a cross leaning against the tower of skulls

The Bone Temple is more optimistic than A Canticle for Leibowitz because while the latter also ends with Abbot Zerchi taking personal responsibility for what Bennett calls “the destiny of men,” by then it’s too late. American Idiot is somewhere in between, and that (plus the fact that it is great to run to) is why I love it. The album concludes with Jesus of Suburbia, having turned his back on both the nihilism of St. Jimmy and the revolution sung by Whatsername, reminiscing about the latter. “And in the darkest night,” he sings on the album’s final track, “If my memory serves me right/I’ll never turn back time/Forgetting you, but not the time.” The Genius annotation for these lyrics optimistically suggests they mean Jesus “doesn’t regret living his life on the streets, using it as a learning experience,” but of course this assumes that he’s going to do something with the knowledge he has gained. The same goes for Spike, whose story, at least for now, has also ended before we get to see what he does with everything Kelson taught him.

Cass Sunstein’s Leibowitz post appeals to me because I am proud of the way this “widely ignored” blog has kept its “focus on events, periods, and documents to which no one seems to be paying attention” for nearly a decade, but the 28 Years Later movies are a reminder that this isn’t enough. You could criticize American Idiot for not offering any answers or celebrate it as a cynically realistic takedown of all my fellow former protest punks for whom “growing up” meant abandoning activism. But I prefer to see it as a challenge: in a world perpetually mired in political crisis, it’s not enough to “Remember . . . whatever”–the question is, are you doing your part to use everything you learned to make things better?

Ithaca Film Journal: 10/15/26

In Theaters: While I’m very curious about You Can See Everything, which opens at Cinemapolis tonight, this week is noteworthy first and foremost for its embarrassment of repertory riches. My top priority is the free screening of a 35mm print of Egyptian auteur Youssef Chahine’s Destiny at Cornell Cinema on Tuesday. You can see my April, 2022 “Drink & a Movie” selection The Hole there on 35mm as well on Saturday. I’m definitely also going to catch The Double Life of Véronique at Cornell Cinema tonight or on Saturday, and while I unfortunately won’t be at the screening of Malombra accompanied by a live score by Donald Sosin and Joanna Seaton there on Sunday, it looks like a cool event. Finally, a new restoration of The Devils is at Cinemapolis all week.

The best new releases I’ve already seen are Digger and NAZA, which continue their runs at the Regal Ithaca Mall and Cinemapolis respectively. Here’s what I recently said about the latter on Letterboxd:

Begins, like Israel Palestine on Swedish TV 1958-1989, on a rooftop, which underscores how tragically un-prophetic that film’s final word “enough!” has proven to be. With disquieting, implacable calmness, NAZA uses the words of its 24 Israeli soldier and intelligence officer interview subjects (who speak from the literal shadows with altered voices to preserve their anonymity) to assert without saying so outright that listening to them is the equivalent of hearing directly from Nazis carrying out the Holocaust while it was still in progress. By juxtaposing their testimony with hypnotic footage of Tel Aviv at night, the film also provocatively suggests that the people of that city may one day reap what their country is sowing. But even if you and your fellow moviegoers disagree sharply about whether either of these suggestions is fair or the degree to which the claims these subjects make should be taken at face value, NAZA can function as a platform for productive debate because the television news reports we glimpse through windows corroborate at least some of them. What if 10% of them are true? Or a quarter? Or half? Or most of them?

First-run fare I’m interested in, but don’t have time for this week, includes Whalefall, which opens at the Regal this afternoon, and Sense and Sensibility, which is there and at Cinemapolis. Finally, special events include a bevy of free events: two more Cine con Cultura screenings as that festival concludes, Makva: The Forest Song at Cornell Cinema on Saturday, a “Family Classics Picture Show” screening of The Ghost and Mr. Chicken at Cinemapolis on Sunday, competing screenings of the silent film The Mystery of the Rocks of Kador and the documentary Where Is Juan Moctezuma? there on Monday, and Everyone Is Lying to You for Money at Cornell Cinema on Wednesday.

Home Video Recommendation: I recently revisited Beau Travail after the director of the film I’m currently writing about for Educational Media Reviews Online cited it as an inspiration, and it struck me that this duel in the Red Sea/Gulf of Aden sun:

Long shot of Denis Lavant's Galoup and Grégoire Colin's Sentain staring each other down from screen left and right respectively on a rocky terrain in front of a glistening blue sea which occupies the top third of the frame

Reminds me more of the version of The Odyssey that Fritz Lang is shooting in Contempt than anything in Christopher Nolan’s recent adaptation! Friend of the blog Brian Darr asks on Letterboxd, “Has the land ever been filmed so inhospitably, and the sea so revivifyingly?” Which: the defining quality of the salt flats which play a prominent role in the movie’s climax is that they are without water, yeah?

Medium long shot of a parched-looking Sentain lying on a salt flat with only his pack to provide shade

Beau Travail also, of course, features a brilliant final shot. It is currently available on HBO Max with a subscription, for rental or purchase from a variety of other streaming video platforms, and on Blu-ray and DVD from the Criterion Collection.

Previous “Ithaca Film Journal” posts can be found here. A running list of all of my “Home Video” recommendations can be found here.

Juxtaposition #30

From Filipiñana:

Close-up of Dr. Palanca (Teroy Guzman) asleep on his desk with the head of a golf club hovering over it
Medium close-up of Isabel (Jorrybell Agoto) holding the same club high over her head, as if prepared to strike

From “Just Lather, That’s All” by Hernando Téllez in Contemporary Latin American Short Stories (Ed. Pat McNees Mancini):

Murderer or hero? My destiny depends on the edge of this blade. I can turn my hand a bit more press a little harder on the razor, and sink it in. The skin would give way like silk, like rubber. There is nothing more tender than human skin and the blood is always there, ready to pour forth.

But I don’t want to be a murderer. You came to me for a shave. And I perform my work honorably . . . I don’t want blood on my hands. Just lather, that’s all. You are an executioner and I am only a barber. Each person has his own place in the scheme of things.

Previous “Juxtaposition” posts can be found here.

Juxtaposition #28

From Mare’s Nest:

Close-up of a turtle
Long shot of Moon Guo Barker's Moon standing next to the white car she just crashed into a tree
Continuation of the previous image: Moon talks to the turtle she has just picked up from the middle of the road next to her car in long shot

MOON: Why are you in the middle of the road? Let me tell you why you’re in the middle of the road. Once, a long, long time ago, there was a tiny molecule riding the surface of the sea.

Our molecule was thrown about. The water was rough, and it had to adapt or break. But then a storm came up, and our molecule was struck by lightning. This charged it with a strange energy. This was the origin of life, or Ool.

So there was our molecule in the sea. Our sea was soupy, warm and dense, with a bloom of oily bubbles in the crest of the waves. Our molecule sealed itself inside one of these bubbles, and that was the first body.

From The Electric Kool-Aid Acid Test by Tom Wolfe:

The whole world was coming to pieces molecule by molecule now and swimming like grease bubbles in a cup of coffee, disappearing into the intergalactic ooze and gasses all around–including his own body. He lost his skin, his skeleton, his pulmonary veins–sneaking out into the ooze like eels, they are, reeking phosphorus, his neural ganglia–unraveling like hot worms and wiggling down the galactic drain, his whole substance dissolving into gaseous nothingness until finally he was down to one cell. One human cell: his; that was all that was left of the entire known world, and if he lost control of that one cell, there would be nothing left. The world would be, like, over. He has to rebuild himself and the entire world from that one cell with a gigantic act of will–too overwhelming. Where does a man start? With California Route 1 so he can get out of here in his car? or will it turn out to be merely the filthy Rue Ventru with the Bastille mobs waiting? or start with the car? the differential? how do they make the bastards? or the beach? all those freaking grains of sand? the marsh grass? the tourist cabins? got to put every blue door back? or the ocean? or leave it dry? save making all those filthy blind bathosphere black animals down there . . . or the sky? how far does it go? the Big Dipper? the Ursa Minor? the Delphinium? suppose it is really infinite concentric spheres of crystal making infinite gelatinous submarinal vibrations? the Dead? the Pranksters? Kesey, Kesey’s out for good, Kesey and the bathosphere brutes–but with a superheroic effort he begins. But by the time he gets himself remade, it is too much. It is overwhelming. He makes his car. He makes the parking lot and the beginning of the road out. He’ll make the rest of it as he goes along. Freak it! Split! Leave the rest of the known world to its own devices, out in the gasses. He jumped into the car and gunned off; and smashed it into a tree. A tree he hadn’t even put back yet. But the crash somehow pops the whole world back. There it is; back from the fat-bubbling ooze. The car is smashed, but he has survived. Survived!

Previous “Juxtaposition” posts can be found here.

A Brilliant Psychological Essay

I started smoking my freshman year of college, as one does, and continued to inhale a pack or two a week for the next ten years or so. I stopped when my oldest daughter was on the way, but the first thing I do whenever she and her sister and My Loving Wife Marion go out of town for more than a few days is pop across the street to buy a pack of Pall Malls. The ability to “take it or leave it” that I tell myself this represents was always the ideal for my relationship with alcohol as well, but like many people I started to imbibe more during the pandemic and never recalibrated until the waning days of my “Drink & a Movie” project, when I decided that my liver had earned a six-month vacation.

In this regard I was not unlike the four friends in Another Round, which interestingly took home the Academy Award for Best International Feature Film at the ceremony most closely associated with COVID. Although it opens with a pre-credit sequence depicting inebriated high schoolers competing in a “lake race” that requires each team to consume an entire case of beer and wreaking havoc on Copenhagen’s public transit system:

Long shot of a large group of teens assembled at the starting line of a race with cases of beer
Low angle close-up of a teen chugging a beer
Medium long shot of beers spraying a light rail car with beer

The plot starts with Mads Mikkelsen’s Martin declining to drink at a 40th birthday celebration for his fellow teacher Nikolaj (Magnus Millang). It has previously been established that he has become a shadow of his younger self:

Long shot of Martin sitting in a chair in a home office silhouetted by a window

“Too bad you’re so sensible,” says their friend Peter (Lars Ranthe). “But the question is, what’s sensible?” asks Nikolaj and leaps into an account of what he describes as a “theory” by the Norwegian philosopher and psychiatrist Finn Skårderud that “humans are born with a blood alcohol content (BAC) that’s 0.05% too low.”

Medium shot of Nikolaj in a dimly-lit restaurant

Which, Skårderud later told the Norwegian Broadcasting Corporation, is “fake news,” although he noted in the same interview that he served “as a sort of consultant” on the film at the request of director Thomas Vinterberg and characterized its depiction of drinking as “balanced.” Anyway, Martin’s resolve breaks down during a caviar service that includes vodka that per their sommelier “would put a smile on the Tsar’s face”:

Close-up of vodka being poured into a flight of four glasses

And after Nikolaj takes the liberty of ordering a “really, really good glass of wine for Martin” prior to the arrival of the main course, then another when he downs it in one gulp:

Close-up of Martin downing a glass of red wine in one gulp

The evening turns into a bacchanal that’s more fun than he’s had in years. Martin decides to put Skårderud to the test the next weekday by bringing a fifth of Smirnoff to school:

Close-up of Martin's hands unscrewing the top off a fifth of Smirnoff

Nikolaj finds out when Martin asks him for a ride home and immediately calls Peter and their fourth dinner companion Tommy (Thomas Bo Larsen) to propose an experiment: they will drink during working hours in quantities that will help them maintain Skårderud’s supposed 0.05% BAC ideal, stopping each day at 8pm and taking weekends off, with the goal of collecting evidence of “increased social and professional performance.” They, too, decide to clothe their project in literary aspirations, although whereas for me “Drink & a Movie” was a means to the end of writing more, the “brilliant psychological essay” they are ostensibly going to produce is more transparently an academic justification for behavior their employer and families presumably wouldn’t approve of. Crucially, they also neglect to define a time limit like I did early on, and thus fail to pace themselves, first increasing their target BAC to .1% on a very flimsy pretext, and then impulsively deciding to “examine the entire spectrum of alcohol” by deliberately drinking to the point of “total oblivion,” which has predictable results:

Medium shot of Peter drunkenly sprawled out in the aisle of a grocery store's liquor section where he has fallen, making a mess
Long shot of four obviously drunken men walking and running through nighttime Copenhagen in the middle of the street
Medium long shot of Martin, who has a nasty-looking cut on his head, passed out in the middle of a driveway as his neighbors attempt to rouse him

My project never got out of hand like this, but I definitely was ready for it to be over long before it was scheduled to end. While my intention was never to quit for good, I hope I haven’t ever come off like Anders Mossling’s asshole art gallery owner from The Love That Remains, who ruins a business lunch by droning on and on about a research study that he claims proved that it was healthy to drink up to an entire bottle of wine a day, but remains virtually unknown because its findings are “politically incorrect.”

Medium long shot of Saga Garðarsdóttir's Anna listening patiently while her lunch companion pontificates over the meal they're eating in front of a window

Alcohol is a vice, and much the same way that I don’t see a contradiction between betting on sports while supporting increased regulations, I’m glad to see society continuing to grow out of self-destructive norms like those depicted in the mid-century period piece Propeller: One-Way Night Coach:

Medium shot of Clark Shotwell's Jeff looking on as his mother Helen lights a cigarette in the airplane seat next to him
Continuation of the previous image: the camera has panned up to reveal a smoky cabin full of men also enjoying cigarettes

Even as I’m envious of the drink service Kelly Eviston-Quinnett’s Helen receives while flying coach:

Medium shot of Olga Hoffmann's flight attendant Liz serving Helen a Manhattan in a proper coupe glass

Just because I choose to drink doesn’t mean I feel the need to make a virtue out of it or that I’m entitled to do so whenever and wherever I want! After all, the main lesson my time off taught me is that much more of my caloric intake from alcohol than I ever imagined was truly “empty” in the sense that it wasn’t coming from beverages I prepared for myself because I wanted them, but rather ones I made simply as a result of not having anything better to do. What drove this home for me was a scene from Happy Gilmore 2. Adam Sandler’s titular protagonist has retired from golf and started drinking as an escape from accidentally killing his wife Virginia (Julie Bowen) with an errant drive. Forced to stop after an incident involving public drunkenness, he takes the sport back up again to earn money to put his daughter (Sunny Sandler) through ballet school when John Daly (who is hilarious playing himself) convinces him that it will be worth all the practice time required to shake off the rust by arguing, “what else are you going to do, sober boy? You can’t drink no more.”

Medium shot of a bearded John Daly in a green golf shirt and garish pants gesturing from a green armchair

I also discovered that not having the option of making a cocktail regularly led to me doing something completely unrelated and useful, such as going for a run. Again and again I’d find myself thinking, “I’d normally be drinking right now, but I don’t miss it.” Abstinence just as often resulted in me choosing to go with a sugary soft drink instead, though, and as Tony Leung and Sylvester Groth’s characters find in Silent Friend, there’s a lot to be said for the way booze can make boredom itself productive:

Long shot of two men clinking beer bottles as they sit on a park bench in the foreground in front of a giant ginkgo tree they've just pollinated

The main thing, I think, is not to deceive oneself, which is a note for the people behind the camera, too. François Truffaut famously once told Gene Siskel that “every film about war ends up being pro-war,” and to pick on a movie I like, the “Come Undone” sequence from Better Man is a good demonstration of how trying to make drinking look dangerous always carries the risk of portraying it as tragically glamorous instead:

Close-up of a car's speedometer bathed in red light and reading 90 miles per hour
Striking red-green composition showing a car emerging from a "portal" into an underwater landscape lit only by its headlights
Long shot of Robbie Williams spread eagle in the water lit by the car's headlights

To its credit, the film does course-correct by depicting Robbie Williams’ rock bottom as, in the words of Clint Worthington, “a monkey weeping over lines of coke while dressed in a space-age fat-sucking vacuum suit”:

Close-up of Williams, who is depicted as a chimpanzee, lifting his head up from a table covered in cocaine
Medium long shot of Williams in the aforementioned "space-age-fat-sucking-vacuum-suit" chugging a beer in a messy kitchen as his best friend looks on from the foreground in silhouette

Much the same way that Happy Gilmore 2 chooses to make its hero’s problem drinking into a running joke about how he can turn literally anything into a flask:

Medium shot of Happy Gilmore drinking out of a cucumber
Medium shot of Happy Gilmore on the floor of a bathroom with his trademark Bruins jersey, drinking out of a cellphone
Extreme long shot of Happy Gilmore on the golf course drinking out of one of his clubs in the left of the frame as he walks past a sand trap

But while I absolutely do not mean to argue that the topic should be considered off-limits for any movie that chooses to tackle it, I am intrigued by the way Power Ballad replaces the spirits that would typically lead to its hero questioning his life choices with non-alcoholic beer, which pointedly renders booze irrelevant.

Medium long shot of Paul Rudd's Rick in a hospital recovery room with his wife (Marcella Plunkett) and daughter (Beth Fallon)

Such scenes are perhaps best saved for ones that take substance abuse as their actual subject, like If I Had Legs I’d Kick You, which channels Cormac McCarthy’s post-apocalyptic novel The Road in a cautionary tale I now take even more to heart about how there’s a proper time and a place to imbibe. That whole movie can be read as a feature-length gloss on these two sentences: “he’d found four quarts of bonded whiskey still in the paper bags in which they’d been purchased and he drank a little of it in a glass with water. It made him dizzy before he’d even finished it and he drank no more.” The argument of Legs being that when the time and place are never and nowhere like they are for Rose Byrne’s Linda, that’s a problem with the world, not any individual trying to live within it.

Close-up of Linda, who is obviously stoned, looking puzzled as she tries to purchase three bottles of wine
Close-up of Ivy Wolk's hotel manager Diana pointing offscreen right from behind the cash register
Close-up of Linda, out of focus in the left foreground, looking at the sign Diana is pointing at, which reads "No Alcohol After 2am"

This thankfully isn’t the case for me, but even though my kids are getting older and don’t require constant attention like Linda’s daughter, I’m finding myself waiting until after they go to bed to fix a drink now that I’m no longer conditioned to head straight to our bar as soon as I hear the clock strike five. After all, as director Paul Feig said to the BBC last year, cocktails are one of the great perks of the adult world.

That word “adult” brings us back to Another Round and the binge-drinking youths it begins with. Supergirl similarly starts out with Milly Alcock’s Kara getting plastered as a rite of passage:

Medium close-up of a clearly hungover Kara sleeping under a red blanket while still wearing a pair of askew sunglasses
Blue-toned medium close-up of Kara downing a glass of alcohol in an extraterrestrial dive bar
Close-up of Kara waking up on the floor with another hangover from under the same blanket as the first image in this sequence

But where the only real consequences for her are hangovers that she can easily shake off with a shot of yellow sun, Martin and his pals represent a range of eventual outcomes for their students. Nothing all that bad ever happens to Peter, and he even helps a student pass his oral exams by irresponsibly (“don’t make a habit of it,” he says) encouraging him to take swigs from a bottle of “water” to calm his nerves:

Medium close-up of Peter holding a bottle of "water" up to his student, who has his back to the camera in the right foreground

On the other side of the spectrum is Tommy, who meets the same fate as Icarus:

Medium close-up of Tommy on a boat with his dog positioned in front of the sun

Nikolaj’s incontinence leads to a separation, but he reports that in its aftermath he and his wife “have a new kind of connection”:

Medium shot of Nikolaj updating Peter and Martin on the state of his marriage as they sit around a table at the restaurant from earlier in the movie

While Martin progresses in the opposite direction, first rekindling his own marriage and career, but then pushing his wife away and falling back into a malaise at work when the buzz wears off:

Medium close-up of Martin looking depressed in front of the blackboard in his classroom

The movie concludes with him receiving a series of texts from her that say “I miss you too . . . a lot,” though, indicating that hope is far from lost.

Medium long shot of Martin standing in a doorway reading a text in silhouette

In these final moments he reminds me a bit of Ralph Fiennes’ David Henninger from The Forgiven, who accepts an ice-cold beer from Mourad Zaoui’s previously skeptical butler Hamid as a reward for what they both see as a “noble gesture,” agreeing to accompany the father (Ismael Kanater) of the Berber fossil hunter he ran over with his car on a voyage to bury the boy in the deserts of southern Morocco where he was born. Along with the shirt David purchases on the way back and wears to dinner that night:

Exterior daytime medium shot of David examining a red shirt in the local style that hangs on a rack with his back to the camera
Exterior nighttime close-up of David wearing the shirt from the previous image

The greedy satisfaction he takes in this pint does a pretty amazing job of capturing the decidedly uncinematic note that Lawrence Osborne finishes the novel that the film was adapted from on: “it never occurred to him why he had not been forgiven, because he had forgiven himself.”

Close-up of David drinking a pint of beer
Continuation of the previous image: David tilts the glass, which is now half empty, back
Continuation of the previous two images: having finished the pint in one draught, David lets out an ecstatic sigh

It’s too bad that director John Michael McDonagh didn’t have the good sense to realize it! But the Hollywood ending which follows doesn’t matter for our purposes. What does is the pleasure David so obviously takes in this would-be benedictory tipple. He is perhaps being too generous to himself, but this is in part because Hamid gives him permission in the form of a smile:

Close-up of Hamid beaming at David, who is offscreen

It’s an act of hospitality, which even more than wearing the right thing and having the right glass is what makes an adult beverage the special moment Paul Feig says cocktails in particular should always be. Such is the case with the Manhattan that Colman Domingo’s titular protagonist orders in Rustin to usher a drinking companion into a new world. “After two you’ll be a changed man,” he says:

Close-up of Bayard Rustin sitting at a bar talking to Elias Taylor (who has his back to the camera in the foreground) while he smokes a cigarette

To which Johnny Ramey’s Elias Taylor replies, “well in that case give me three”:

Close-up of Taylor responding to Rustin with the blocking reversed from the previous image
Close-up of a coupe glass being filled from a shaker in front of a bottle of Angostura bitters

There have been at least that many great versions of this favorite concoction in my own life, most recently the “house” Manhattan that Marion and I finally perfected last month. Years in the making, it’s designed to be shared. We drink them plenty often when it’s just us, to be sure, but even then each one is cause for celebration.

Another Round ends with Martin sending his spouse one last text which reads, “I think Tommy is rooting for you.” When she replies with a message that says, “me too,” he joins his friends in celebrating their students’ graduation with them in the street, throwing himself into a euphoric dance that culminates in a leap into Copenhagen Harbour:

Long shot of Martin suspended in mid-air as he dives into Copenhagen Harbour

The movie leaves him suspended in mid-air because it’s too early to say whether or not he, unlike Henninger, has said what he had to. In this moment, it doesn’t matter. The lyrics of the Scarlet Pleasure song which plays over this scene go, “fuck what they are saying, what a life.” But there’s another way to express this sentiment, and it’s the same way I capped off all my Drink & a Movie posts:

Cheers!