Top Ten Movies of 2024 + Oscar Picks

Last March I celebrated being fully back to “using cinema as a window on the world and a lens through which I can interrogate my thoughts and feelings and refine them into a more consistent and generous philosophy” with my first proper top ten list in many years. In the same post I mentioned the “mixtapes” I’ve been compiling bi-annually for the past decade and started sharing on this blog in 2022, but I didn’t quite make the connection that these are essentially the same activity.

Although I’ve historically been adamant that, as I said in 2021, the songs I include on my mixes “are not necessarily the best songs of the previous six months in my opinion, but rather the ones that gave me the most pleasure and/or affected me the most,” it recently struck me that after more than a decade of listening to hundreds of new albums each year, I likely know more about music than I give myself credit for, at least on an intuitive level; conversely, although I watch hundreds of new movies each year and also spend quite a bit of time immersed in older ones, my knowledge of cinema relative to people who write about it professionally isn’t nearly what it used to be in my 20s when I was fresh out of a film studies program and could afford to live as though I did as well. Even back then I tried to embrace my amateur status: that’s when I came up with the idea of a “movie year” that starts and ends in March instead of January, for instance. Just paying attention isn’t a surefire way to avoid falling into imitative patterns, though, and I recently found myself pondering whether or not this annual list-making exercise serves any purpose for me at all. Delaying its creation makes it a truer representation of my favorites from 2024 by allowing two extra months for many of the most important titles that posterity will label with that year to reach Ithaca and the streaming video services I subscribe to, sure, but is it really worth the time and effort?

To my very great surprise, the answer to this question came from my younger self. Nearly twenty years ago I wrote the following:

I suppose that it’s possible to construct a Top Ten that would satisfy me structured around a list of films numbered from 1-10 that devotes one or two sentences to each movie, with a paragraph-long introduction and conclusion. Possible, but certainly not likely–at any rate, there are better ways. A good list might include scenes from films or lines of dialogue. It can include upcoming films, old films, ideas for films. Buildings. Political scandals. People. Why not? If you’ve explained your goals adequately it can include anything.

At the very least it can include nine films, or eleven. It can include re-releases, short films, and television episodes/seasons/series.

Or. Or the critic can accept all of the limitations of the Top Ten list and simply scribble down ten films and be done with it. Let the readers do the leg work, right? My editor wants a list? Here you go: a list. Because any list of films is interesting, just not necessarily fraught with any particular meaning.

In the 2004 Village Voice year-end poll Lars von Trier’s Dogville (2003) placed third. This did not mean that Dogville was the year’s third best film. It did not mean that it was the year’s third most important, talked about, or divisive film. All that it meant was that Dogville finished third in the Village Voice‘s year-end poll. But by finishing third in this poll Dogville set off a round of discussion about itself, Lars von Trier, the Voice poll, year-end polls in general, and the movies that was important, talked about, and divisive.

What am I saying? I’m suggesting that we don’t need to do away with year-end polls entirely, but that we need to either think more about them or give them less space. That we need to strive to make them relevant and to articulate why we think we’ve succeeded, or that we need to treat them like coffee table books: as conversation starters, and nothing more.

It pains me to see so. many. italics, but I have to admit that the kid has a point. More than one, even! Top ten lists are inherently the kind of endeavor that most people are going to spend either too much time on or too little. Like movie reviews they have value in the aggregate, too, but each individual one of them says more about the person who compiled it than the films they selected, and the list maker can’t just assume that readers already have the necessary context to make sense of their choices–they have to provide it. Professional film critics probably don’t have much say in the matter: they have to deliver whatever the publication they write for wants on deadline with a word count. There’s nothing stopping me, though, from using as much space I need in order to not just explain my picks, but also canvass the entire pool of works I was choosing from and explore how it came to be. What made it to Ithaca . . . and what didn’t? What did I decide not to watch and why? Are there movies that I think the world needs which aren’t even being made?

The problem is that I don’t actually *want* to write this post. I do this for fun, after all, and I’m impatient to move on to Movie Year 2025. And that brings me back to the idea of a playlist. I only recently started providing any commentary at all about the songs on my mixes: initially I just shared the track listing and a Spotify link and called it a day because the idea was for people to actually listen to everything. And that’s true of my favorite films of the year as well! The 13 mentioned below are my answer to the hypothetical question “what should I watch?” They’re the ones I’m most eager to talk about and I can’t resist the urge to add a bit more commentary here, but I’ve already written about everything on Letterboxd and/or this blog at least once, and frankly I’m more interested in having an actual conversation than pontificating further, so please do check them out for yourself and tell me what you think!

Speaking of Letterboxd, one of the main reasons I can barely imagine life without it anymore despite becoming the last cinephile on earth to join little more than 18 months ago is because it makes it super easy to ascertain that I tagged 124 films “Movie Year 2024.” By way of illustrating what does and doesn’t qualify, when I watch Queer after it debuts on Max next month, I won’t tag it “Movie Year 2025” because it played Ithaca in December; however, Universal Language *will* qualify even though it was screened at the 2024 editions of Cannes and TIFF and a bunch of other film festivals because when it opens at Cinemapolis next week, that will be my first opportunity to see it. Anyway, I also saw everything in the Indiewire Critics Poll and CriticsTop10 top 50 lists except Queer and Youth (Hard Times), all of which means that, 1) my local movie theaters are awesome, and 2) this is basically the “top 10% in the class.” Here are the new releases I liked best:

10. Green Border. One of three movies I spent a lot of time thinking about this year as representative of philosophically different takes on the efficacy of depicting horrific acts of injustice. Green Border occupies the optimistic/determined quadrant: director Agnieszka Holland clearly believes that shining a light on the evil deeds desensitized people do in the dark when told enough times that it’s their job and/or their duty will eventually put a stop to them. No Other Land is similarly optimistic, but resigned to the possibility that we the viewers just don’t have the attention span anymore, while Incident is pessimistic but nonetheless keen to continue the fight.

8. Here. Perhaps the most formally audacious and emotionally satisfying film on this list and connected thematically to a number of the rest. Including:

8. La Chimera. Above-ground/beneath-the-surface cantastoria about what it means to live a good life: if your heart’s desire is buried in the dirt under your feet, do you build a shrine on it or dig?

8. About Dry Grasses. When you spend 197 minutes with an unsympathetic character and don’t tire of them, the movie they’re in did something right! Reminded me of college.

6. All We Imagine as Light. Either this film’s adaptation of the Phosphorescent song “Christmas Down Under” or the camera movement at the end of Here was my favorite closing shot of the year.

5. Close Your Eyes. Do you have to know you’re doing it for your life to be your art? Makes an interesting pairing with my first and maybe always favorite cinematic depiction of Ithaca My First Film in the way it depicts a filmmaker engaging with a work made in their youth.

4. Red Rooms. Perhaps the year’s most well-constructed movie. I am planning to write about its poker scenes after my “Drink & a Movie” series wraps in December.

3. Do Not Expect Too Much from the End of the World. History is supposedly written by the victors, but the idea of “winning” is as slippery as quote attribution and the fossil record and racial memory are harder to control than state media and schools, so if you’re thinking in a long enough timeframe, it’s more accurate to say that points will be tallied based on surviving documentation.

2. Evil Does Not Exist. Another film that explores the societal implications of the ideas about personal happiness that appealed to me so much in some of the titles on this list.

1. I Saw the TV Glow. Presumptive shoo-in for any Best of the 2020s list I might someday make along with Crimes of the Future and Petite Maman.

* * *

I also saw a number of terrific older films for the first time last year. Here are the ones that made the biggest impressions:

5. Whiplash. There are still a number of prominent movies released during my period of self-imposed semi-exile from “the lost continent of cinephilia” that I haven’t caught up with yet, but I’ll be surprised if I enjoy any of them half as much as I did Whiplash!

4. Man’s Castle. Instantly my second-favorite movie directed by Frank Borzage after my September “Drink & a Movie” selection History Is Made at Night.

3. House of Usher. I wrote about this film in the next entry in that series.

2. The Act of Killing. This is what the pessimistic/resigned quadrant in the framework I started to sketch out when talking about Green Border looks like.

1. The Long Day Closes. A legit contender for my 2032 Sight & Sound “Greatest Films of All Times” ballot!

* * *

Porcelain War played Cinemapolis for one week in January so I definitely did have an opportunity to see *all* of the films up for Oscars tonight! I guess I’ll have to settle for 48 out of 49. As always, these are the films I’m rooting for, not the ones I expect to win.

Actress in a Supporting Role: Ariana Grande – Wicked

Animated Short: Wander to Wonder

Animated Feature Film: Flow

Original Screenplay: A Real Pain

Adapted Screenplay: A Complete Unknown. I won’t be at all disappointed if Nickel Boys wins, but I loved Pete Seeger’s strategically ill-advised speech about the “teaspoon brigade” and the placement of Joan Baez’s comment “you’re kind of an asshole, Bob.”

Makeup & Hairstyling: The Substance. Demi Moore’s Elisabeth Sparkle’s first prematurely decrepit finger was one of Movie Year 2024’s standout moments for me.

Production Design: The Brutalist

Costume Design: Wicked

International Feature Film: I’m Still Here

Actor in a Supporting Role: Kieran Culkin – A Real Pain

Visual Effects: Dune: Part Two

Film Editing: The Brutalist

Documentary Short: Incident. The only way I won’t throw something at the television if it doesn’t win is if Instruments of a Beating Heart does instead.

Documentary Feature: No Other Land

Cinematography: The Brutalist. I’m incredulous that Nickel Boys wasn’t nominated in this category.

Live-Action Short: A Lien

Sound: Dune: Part Two

Original Score: The Brutalist

Original Song: “Mi Camino”Emilia Pérez. But how did “Claw Machine” from I Saw the TV Glow not even make the shortlist?

Actor in a Leading Role: Ralph Fiennes – Conclave. Give the man an Oscar already!

Directing: Brady Corbet – The Brutalist.

Actress in a Leading Role: Demi Moore – The Substance

Best Picture: The Brutalist.

Top Ten Movies of 2023

When I launched this blog five and a half years ago in 2018, my reasons for naming it Prodigal Cinephile were partly aspirational. Sure enough, although I easily kept up with the pace I set for myself of at least six essays per year supplemented by occasional short posts for its first eight months of existence, a move across state lines in summer 2019 derailed me for the rest of that year. I returned briefly in early 2020, but then the world turned upside down and I only published twice more before the end of 2021. Inspiration struck shortly afterward, though, when it occurred to me that tying a movie to the cocktail recipes I was writing on a chalkboard in my dining room every month might prove to be a good way of generating regular content. It did indeed and 29 posts later, that series is still going strong! One year later I decided to make a point of tweeting something about every new movie I saw. Although this idea didn’t stand the test of time, it did result in me becoming the last cinephile on earth to join Letterboxd this past summer, which I have found to be the perfect place to jot down notes that I can refer back to later. The final piece of the puzzle fell into place this fall when turned my weekly study of Ithaca, New York movie showtimes, into a platform for brief commentary on what I’m seeing in theaters and watching at home.

So it is that I look around today and see that at long last I’m truly back to using cinema as a window on the world and a lens through which I can interrogate my thoughts and feelings and refine them into a more consistent and generous philosophy. I believe that seeing one film a week in theaters really does make me a better person, and it occurred to me the other day that my daughters may someday find all these writings interesting, which ought to provide additional motivation at times when my energy is at low ebb and thus increase the sustainability of my approach even further. Just as the “mixtapes” I’ve been making bi-annually for the past decade have encouraged me to explore a ton of music I probably wouldn’t have discovered otherwise, having a system has exposed me to a larger, more adventurous selection of movies as well. Since last year’s Oscars, for instance, I have seen 117 new films (including 51 in theaters, where I also attended 28 repeat or repertory screenings). I also managed to catch 39 of the top 50 finishers in the IndieWire Critics’ Poll, 42 of the top 50 on the Critics’ Top Ten Best Movies of 2023 list, and everything in either one’s top 25 except John Wick: Chapter Four, which my loving wife and I are saving for a movie marathon since we haven’t seen any of the three previous films in the series either. To be sure, my 25-year-old self would not be impressed! But he had a lot more free time on his hands and for the first time in ages, I feel like I sampled enough of what Movie Year 2023 had to offer to make a top ten list reflective more of my tastes than what I missed.

Before I get into my selections, why am I doing this in March instead of December like everybody else? The answer is simple: many of the year’s most important films don’t make it as far as Ithaca until after January 1 and our local theaters are dominated by Academy Award nominees in the weeks leading up to the ceremony. As someone who isn’t able to travel to see movies more than a handful of times each year, Oscar night therefore makes much more sense to me as an occasion to mark the end of one year and the beginning of another. Without further ado, then, here are my favorite films of 2023:

10. Mambar Pierrette

Rosine Mbakam’s debut narrative feature seems like the culmination of the lessons learned from the four documentaries she directed between 2018-23 and promises great things to come. The reason it’s on this list, though, is because of its depiction of a Cameroonian seamstress (Pierrette Aboheu Njeuthat in the year’s best performance by a non-professional actor) who perseveres through hardship thanks to the self-worth that fulfilling work, a loving family, and supportive community have given her and a sudden pivot away from what initially appears to be a descent into miserabilism into something far more surprisingly, wise, and hopeful which made me laugh out loud with delight.

9. A Thousand and One

I started getting into movies in high school in large part because they served as a gateway to other forms of expression like literature, fashion, and most especially music. The days when the soundtrack to a movie like 24 Hour Party People could completely rock my universe are mostly gone, but I still appreciate discovering something new. A Thousand and One featured my favorite original movie music of the year, and I gave the opening theme by Gary Gunn pride of place on my 2023: The Mixtape, Vol. 1 compilation. I was also impressed by Teyana Taylor’s lead performance as a pressure-hardened, combustible woman named Inez de la Paz, and by the slow metamorphosis of an empty apartment into a home followed by its sudden collapse into haunted ruin.

8. 20 Days in Mariupol

Transformation is one of the subjects of 20 Days in Mariupol as well, in this case the reduction of a thriving city into a desolate wasteland in less than three weeks after Russia’s invasion of Ukraine in February, 2022. Director Mstyslav Chernov situates the devastating images of Ukrainian citizens of all ages suffering for the crime of living too close to an area of strategic importance that he and his fellow and Associated Press journalists made famous in the context of the other footage they shot, which in many cases is far too graphic for television. Timely for its unflinching depiction of war crimes committed by the Russian Federation; timeless as a reminder that until we grow up as a species, no human being on this planet is ever more than a few days away from having every good thing in their life utterly destroyed.

7. The Teachers’ Lounge

A feature-length rebuttal to the blackboard scene in A Christmas Tale which I wrote about two years ago. Leonie Benesch’s Carla Nowak and Leonard Stettnisch’s Oskar are, like that film’s Claude (Hippolyte Girardot) and Abel (Jean-Paul Roussillon), believers in the power of logic and mathematics to help us navigate the ground before us, no matter how rocky it is. But a Rubik’s Cube is nothing compared to the social dynamics of a modern school, and far from showing them the way to freedom, all of their calculations just make everything worse. Benesch is magnificent, as are the actors who play the “bad” teachers, who bring just enough humanity to their roles to make us being to wonder if our perception of them is the result of testimony from an unreliable narrator when things start to go haywire, especially when combined with the claustrophobic framing and Marvin Miller’s tense score.

6. Poison

My favorite of the five movies directed by Wes Anderson which were released in 2023. Each of the four shorts based on Roald Dahl stories is a fine adaptation, but Poison does the best job of honoring and enhancing its source material through decisions like having Ben Kingsley’s Dr. Ganderbai hold objects like a piece of rubber tubing, bottle of alcohol, and syringe up to the camera as Dev Patel’s Timber Woods narrates in rapid-fire staccato on from the other half of a split-screen composition to draw attention to Dahl’s specific word choices and the camera work and lighting which lead up to the completely original ending.

5. All of Us Strangers

All of Us Strangers would make a great double feature with Petite Maman, one of my favorite movies from 2022, which also suggests that understanding our parents (or, conversely, our children) is an undertaking which is neither precisely poetic or psychological, but something else. It contains some of favorite scenes of the year, including the opening shot, an all-time great Christmas sequence starring the song “Always on My Mind” by the Pet Shop Boys which I think I’ve listened to at least once a day since seeing it, and Andrew Scott’s Adam literally forgetting how to be intimate with someone, which is not something I can remember ever seeing on screen before, but which I assure you can happen! Scott is brilliant, as are Paul Mescal, Claire Foy, and Jamie Bell, and there’s a shaking head on a train that reminded me of the painter Francis Bacon via the film Jacob’s Ladder.

4. The Boy and the Heron

I discovered director Hayao Miyazaki in college, but my daughters are growing up with his films. My Neighbor Totoro was a staple of their earliest years, and now The Boy and the Heron has arrived in their lives at a time when my oldest is struggling to make her peace with the concept of mortality. She still isn’t quite old enough to really dive into it, but now she knows it’s waiting for her when she’s ready. My line on this movie is that if it had been playing the 2002 Toronto Film Festival instead of Spirited Away, I believe my life would have been changed in much the same way. That remains true, but I’ve stopped telling everyone how surprised I am that I enjoyed the dubbed version as much as the subtitled one now that I’ve read David Ehrlich’s IndieWire article about how much work went into it. Joe Hisaishi’s score was my second favorite of the year after A Thousand and One.

3. Menus-Plaisirs — Les Troisgros

Although this four-hour long portrait of the Les Troisgros family of restaurants directed by legendary documentarian Frederick Wiseman earned a spot on my list while The Taste of Things didn’t, the latter’s Dodin Bouffant (Benoît Magimel) would surely be gratified to see what kind of hands French gastronomy is in and to know that they’re still consulting Escoffier on the proper cleaning and cooking of brains nearly a century after his death! It’s constructed like a progressive menu that only fully comes together in the dessert course, and the pace is deliberately unhurried except when it’s not, mirroring the rhythm of a high-end kitchen. Effective pairings can be contrasting as well as congruent, and Menus-Plaisirs — Les Troisgros would also go well with one of my favorite films from last year, The Menu, were it not for its length: whereas the latter’s Hawthorn was hermetically sealed off from the rest of the world, this movie’s Le Bois sans Feuilles is integrated into its surroundings via relationships with the farmers and artisans that supply its ingredients and more accessible offshoot establishments like a food truck.

2. The Killer

The Killer is in conversation with Le Samouraï from start to finish. Alain Delon’s Jef Costello from the latter film is the very epitome of cool, but his apartment is so monochromatically drab that I genuinely wonder if it was a reference for the North Pole scenes from Elf. It’s unlikely that anyone will want to emulate the fashion choices of Michael Fassbender’s unnamed assassin from The Killer, but when he’s not hanging out in abandoned WeWork offices, he lives in a palatial home in the Dominican Republic with a beautiful woman (Sophie Charlotte) who appears to really love him. Both have knowledge of a shadow world of garages and storage units where a person with the right connections can pick up new license plates or guns and they ply their trade not with futuristic gizmos, but everyday objects: Costello uses the biggest keychain you’ve ever seen to steal cars, while Fassbender breaks into “high-security” penthouses with a tool he buys online and retrieves from an Amazon Locker. Finally, the two films have basically the same ending: these men live by a strict code that liberates them, but also dictates their fate. What fascinates me about The Killer is how dramatically different its conclusion feels despite the fact that Fassbender’s character isn’t any more or less noble or rigorous than Costello’s — it’s all in how the story is told. Unless you too spent huge portions of your teens and twenties carefully adjusting the brim of your fedora and listening to the Smiths, this film won’t resonate with you nearly as much as it does with me, but it’s also technically perfect and features my third-favorite score of the year (by Trent Reznor and Atticus Ross), brilliant cinematography and sound mixing, and Tilda Swinton, so I feel confident in recommending to everyone anyway!

1. Ferrari

Ferrari contains both my favorite small moment and grand set piece from Movie Year 2023, Adam Driver’s Enzo Ferrari deftly twisting his wrist while pouring wine so as not to spill a single drop and the thousand-mile long Mille Miglia road race respectively, which is a testament to the meticulous attention to detail present in every frame. Fellow holiday season release The Iron Claw also did a good job of depicting the extreme emotional and physical toll that professional sports can take on athletes and their families and even gestured toward their role in global politics, which I tend to value much more highly than celebrations of said athletes’ artistry and skill because contemporary television broadcasts have that pretty much down to a science. What separates Ferrari from the crowd is not just that it successfully accomplishes both of these things in one film, but that it shows how they’re two sides of the same coin: Ferrari is a national treasure (in the sense of possessing value for the country of Italy) not just because the cars he builds go fast, but because they push the boundaries of what is possible and safe, which, as he explains to his son Piero (Giuseppe Festinese) in another great scene, is what makes them beautiful. This is not to say that the 1957 Mille Miglia wasn’t a tragedy–the race was rightfully banned after the fatal crash unforgettably depicted in the film. But now consider how many wars have been fought since the wasteful loss of life described in the end titles for Napoleon and tell me why I shouldn’t continue to hold out hope that one day we’ll channel our irrepressibly competitive tribal urges entirely into sports.

* * *

Although no “old” movies totally blew my mind last year, some noteworthy experiences include seeing Matter Out of Place, which would have made my “Most Memorable Films of 2022” list had it arrived in Ithaca sooner, and my first two documentaries directed by Sergey Loznitsa (Babi Yar. Context and The Natural History of Destruction) at the Finger Lakes Environmental Film Festival; attending my first Nitrate Picture Show; and finally catching up with History Is Made at Night on The Criterion Channel. Three other first-time viewings stood out for me:

3. Werckmeister Harmonies

I don’t like to use one text as a cudgel against another, but I’ve been wondering if I would have found The Zone of Interest nearly as distasteful as I did had I not seen Werckmeister Harmonies at the Maine International Film Festival this summer. The latter movie does a fine job of evoking the Holocaust and inviting us to contemplate what happens when the people who commit such atrocities go home to their families at night in just a few scenes–it is really necessary to make their domestic lives the subject of an entire feature-length film?

2. Black Sheep

I watched this on The Criterion Channel in September when they included it in their terrific “Directed by Allan Dwan” series and it was the most fun I had with a movie all year. I have since purchased it on DVD and am now planning to feature it in a “Drink & a Movie” blog post next March–stay tuned!

1. Eijanaika

I watched as many films as I could directed by Shōhei Imamura last year in preparation for a review of Warm Water Under a Red Bridge and this was the one I’d single out as a “must see,” although The Ballad of Narayama is close and now is a great time to watch Black Rain, which is about a family that survives the dropping of an atomic bomb on Hiroshima, with Godzilla Minus One and Oppenheimer both up for Oscars. But I digress somewhat: Eijanaika is a productively messy, sprawling film which captures the end-of-the-world feeling of living through a pivotal moment in history (the Meiji Restoration) that we’re now all lamentably so familiar with.

* * *

Somehow I managed to see 48 out of 52 of this year’s Oscar nominees which means . . . that any predictions I might offer would still be completely useless, since I’ve never put any effort into studying what’s important to Academy voters. This does, however, mean that I have stronger rooting interests than usual! Here’s who I’ll be cheering for in each category:

Animated Feature Film: The Boy and the Heron, obviously, but I enjoyed all of this year’s nominees with the possible exception of Robot Dreams, which I haven’t seen yet.

Actor in a Supporting Role: Robert Downey Jr. for Oppenheimer, but I wish Paul Mescal and/or Jamie Bell had been nominated for their work in All of Us Strangers.

Actress in a Supporting Role: Da’Vine Joy Randolph for The Holdovers.

Documentary Feature Film: 20 Days in Mariupol, obviously, but as with the Animated Feature Film category, I think this is a pretty strong field even though many of my favorite documentaries of the year like Menus-Plaisirs — Les Troisgros and Smoke Sauna Sisterhood weren’t nominated.

Short Film (Live Action): The Wonderful Story of Henry Sugar. I have not yet seen either Invincible or Red, White and Blue, but director Wes Anderson and company set a pretty high bar, so I doubt it matters.

Cinematography: El Conde. Paula Luchsinger’s Carmencita’s baby bird first attempts to fly and vampires over Santiago at night in glorious black and white are some of my favorite images of Movie Year 2023.

Makeup and Hairstyling: Poor Things. Willem Dafoe’s prosthetics are a movie in unto themselves!

Costume Design: Poor Things, but I would not be disappointed to see Barbie win.

International Feature Film: The Teachers’ Lounge, obviously. Note: I have not yet seen Io Capitano.

Documentary Short Film: The Repair Shop, but I would not be disappointed to see Island in Between win.

Short Film (Animated): Letter to a Pig, but I would not be disappointed to see Pachyderme win. Or anything but War Is Over! really.

Production Design: Poor Things, but as with the Costume Design award I would not be disappointed to see Barbie win.

Music (Original Score): Killers of the Flower Moon. RIP Robbie Robertson.

Visual Effects: The Creator, but I would not be disappointed to see Godzilla Minus One win.

Writing (Original Screenplay): The Holdovers.

Writing (Adapted Screenplay): Oppenheimer.

Sound: Oppenheimer.

Music (Original Song): “I’m Just Ken” from Barbie.

Film Editing: Killers of the Flower Moon. Did you know that Thelma Schoonmaker is a 1961 Cornell grad?

Director: Martin Scorsese for Killers of the Flower Moon, but I would not be disappointed to see Christopher Nolan win for Oppenheimer.

Actor in a Leading Role: Colman Domingo for Rustin, but I would not be disappointed to see Cillian Murphy win for Oppenheimer or Paul Giamatti win for The Holdovers.

Actress in a Leading Role: Emma Stone for Poor Things, but I would not be disappointed to see Lily Gladstone win for Killers of the Flower Moon.

Best Picture: Killers of the Flower Moon, but I would not be disappointed to see Oppenheimer win.

Reflections on Movie Year 2022

“Movie Year” is a concept I came up with about 15 years ago when I was living in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. The idea was that even as a person who saw multiple films in theaters each week, I still couldn’t catch all of the year’s most important movies by December 31 because a significant number wouldn’t be released locally until weeks or even months later. This is even more true now that I live in an even smaller city, as demonstrated by the fact that seven Academy Award nominees and a number of other critical favorites have opened in Ithaca, New York since January 1. The Oscars are, in fact, a driver of what makes it to places like here and for good reason–the screening of The Quiet Girl that I attended yesterday was one of the biggest crowds I’ve been part of in awhile, presumably because anyone planning to watch the awards ceremony wants to see as many nominated films as they can before it starts.

Given all this, I think Oscar night makes much more sense than New Year’s Day as a time for someone like me to publish a Top Ten list. Which, for the record, I still find such lists to be useful, especially in aggregate! I peruse IndieWire’s annual critics poll for titles I missed or never got a chance to see to keep an eye out for because they’re likely to be referenced in articles and reviews I read in the future. There is absolutely no reason why someone needs to be a professional critic to publish such a list, but it is important for amateurs to provide context. To say “these are the ten best movies of the year” is to imply that one has seen every film that deserves to be considered for such an honor. A professional critic can fairly be assumed either to have viewed or to have made an informed decision not to view every movie that has opened in the geographic area that the publication they write for covers. Similarly, someone with a “beat” like documentary or science fiction film can fairly be assumed to have seen everything in their area of specialization. When it isn’t obvious what a film’s inclusion or absence on a list means, that list becomes hard to rely on.

My tweets from the past year indicate that I have currently seen approximately 75 movies that opened in the United States in 2022. That’s not a huge number, but it might be interesting to explore why I chose these films and not others, and this could well yield a definition of “best” that would result in a credible list. But to do it right, I’d likely want to watch many of these movies again because I don’t like to rely on my memory when making qualitative judgements. Which, this is actually crucial to my personal relationship with cinema–I don’t necessarily remember films clearly! Not in their entirety, anyway. Specific lines of dialogue, camera movements, and shot compositions stay with me, as do impressions of color, mood, and sound. This is why I like close reading: it’s a way of pinning down things which would otherwise remain elusive. It’s also why I doubt I could hack it as a daily or weekly reviewer. I watch everything I review for Educational Media Reviews Online or write about on this blog at least twice, which obviously takes time. I regard the concepts of “receiving” and “evaluating” works of art that C.S. Lewis describes in An Experiment in Criticism as the origin of my method, such as it is: I try to open myself up to the film as much as possible during the first viewing, then open up my notebook for the second one. Make no mistake about it, though: without those notes, I wouldn’t be able to say very much at all with confidence!

Anyway, like I said I could put a lot of work into developing a framework which enables me to deliver a verdict on Movie Year 2022. But it would be far easier and much more fun to simply look back on what I watched to see what still stands out in my mind, so I’m going to do that instead. Without further ado, here are my most memorable films of the year:

  • Crimes of the Future: My favorite movie of the year by a country mile. Absolutely chock full of unforgettable ideas and images, including the first and last scenes, a post-infection and pain world, first Nadia Litz and Tanaya Beatty and then Viggo Mortensen and Léa Seydoux naked in a device called “Sark autopsy module,” and most especially for me another product by the same manufacturer known as the “breakfasting chair.” I loved every minute of it.
  • Nope: I thought this would be up for at least seven or eight Oscars! Shows what I know. The “creature” shots at the end are absolutely breathtaking.
  • Petite Maman: You will likely notice, as I did, that this list contains multiple films about parents and parenting, which I hope is forgivable from a father of two young children. This was my favorite.
  • The Northman and Maverick: Top Gun: My loving wife and I only got three date nights out at the movies this year and these were two of the films we saw on them. Both were entertaining and fun to talk about afterward. This is not nothing!
  • The Menu: Date night movie number three and my favorite of the lot! I had actually already seen it myself one week prior, making this the only film I saw in theaters twice last year. I spent way too much time squaring the reference to “heirloom masa” with the fact that Hawthorn’s homage to Taco Tuesday looked to me to be made with FLOUR tortillas (I eventually decided they must be “half and half” tortillas), which, please be assured that my poker buddies have already raked me over the coals for this! Anyway, I liked it enough to retroactively add it to one of my Drink & a Movie posts!
  • Aftersun and The Quiet Girl: Wow, those endings! It’s hard for me to objectively assess the latter because I only saw it yesterday, but right now it feels like it belongs here.
  • Happening and Tár: Movies of and for our historical moment.
  • The Forgiven: Because I write about booze and movies and it contains a scene in which Ralph Fiennes’ David Henninger attacks pint of beer with the urgency of a drowning man gasping for air that has everything good and bad about drinking wrapped up in it. Also a more fully-realized use of Tár‘s maneuver of beginning with the end titles. Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri remains a major contemporary blind spot of mine, but based on the films I have seen I think John Michael might be my favorite McDonagh brother?
  • The Banshees of Inisherin: Which, I mean no disrespect to Martin! The key to this film is that Brendan Gleeson’s character isn’t actually a great musician and thus chooses becoming a folk legend as an alternative path to immortality, right?
  • You Won’t Be Alone: Which, I’m fascinated by the idea of *actually* living forever, too, which is what I was talking about when I referred to this film as “an art house version of the Anne Rice vampire novels I grew up with” on Twitter.
  • Athena: For the virtuoso long takes and my sudden realization that, oh! If this was another era, this would be a tale of dynasties and kings!
  • The Whale: I see this film as the tale of a dying writer trying to author his own redemption story and therefore a companion piece of sorts to Mother! Brendan Fraser is outstanding.
  • Puss in Boots: The Last Wish, Roald Dahl’s Matilda the Musical, and Turning Red: My family’s consensus favorite movies of the year.
  • God’s Country and Master: For their hiring and tenure committee deliberation scenes because I’m a higher ed lifer. The latter also resonates with me as someone who currently works at an Ivy League institution.

* * *

I’m not sure I see a ton of value in logging which “old” movies I see in a given year, especially those I watch at home. For what it’s worth, though, my biggest revelations were as follows:

  • Pyaasa and Kaagaz Ke Phool: Both contain some of the most emotionally-charged camera movements and musical numbers of I’ve seen in any movie ever. I’m embarrassed that it took me this long to discover Guru Dutt! I’m currently planning to write about Pyaasa in my October Drink & a Movie post.
  • RR: I am a former rail commuter and train whistles in the distance have always been one of my favorite sounds, so seeing this at Cornell Cinema was a terrific experience!
  • Ahed’s Knee, Memoria, and Neptune Frost: All three would have been among my favorite films of 2021 had had they opened here on time.
  • The Ring: Like The Passion of Joan of Arc and Sunrise: Song of Two Humans, which I also spent time with last year but had seen before, it is a testament to the expressive powers of silent cinema at the dawn of the sound era. Another possible future Drink & a Movie selection.

Also, I doubt anyone else cares, but here’s a procedural note for the sake of posterity: I am hoping (if Twitter survives and remains free) to use the hashtag #onetweettake to quickly identify films eligible for future posts like this one. As such, starting today I will only use it when writing about films from Movie Year 2023 until Oscar night next year, when I’ll begin only using it for films from Movie Year 2024.

* * *

Speaking of the Oscars, they don’t matter to me much when I’m watching tons of movies, because who cares what Academy voters think, or when I’m not seeing very many at all, because what fun is an awards ceremony when you haven’t seen any of the nominated films? When I’m living somewhere in between like I am now, though, they serve as a convenient guide to which film to choose for my weekly theatrical screening and what to do with my weeknight evenings. As a result I managed to see 34 of 39 nominated features and 10 of 15 nominated shorts, which I think is a pretty healthy total! My loving wife and I definitely are planning to watch and here’s what I’ll be rooting for, with the number of nominees I saw in parentheses:

Actor in a Leading Role (5/5): Brendan Fraser, The Whale.

Actor in a Supporting Role (5/5): Brendan Gleeson, The Banshees of Inisherin. This was the hardest category for me to pick by far. For MONTHS I thought I was going to pick Ke Huy Quan, then strongly considered Brian Tyree Henry, but in the end I couldn’t go against a great performance by one of my favorite actors.

Actress in a Leading Role (4/5): Michelle Yeoh, Everything Everywhere All at Once. Full disclosure: I have no problem whatsoever with so-called “legacy picks.”

Actress in a Supporting Role (5/5): Angela Bassett, Black Panther: Wakanda Forever.

Animated Feature Film (5/5): Turning Red.

Cinematography (5/5): Darius Khondji, Bardo: False Chronicle of a Handful of Truths.

Costume Design (5/5): Ruth Carter, Black Panther: Wakanda Forever.

Directing (5/5): Todd Field, Tár. I see the controversies of content and form that this film has generated as testaments to its effectiveness.

Documentary Feature Film (3/5): All That Breathes. I’m sorry that I didn’t get to see All the Beauty and the Bloodshed before making this pick!

Documentary Short Film (4/5): Haulout.

Film Editing (4/5): Eddie Hamilton, Top Gun: Maverick.

International Feature Film (5/5): The Quiet Girl.

Makeup and Hairstyling (4/5): Adrien Morot, Judy Chin and Annemarie Bradley, The Whale.

Original Score (5/5): Justin Hurwitz, Babylon. This would have been harder to pick if Empire of Light or The Northman had gotten nominations, but I may well have made the same choice.

Original Song (4/5): “Naatu Naatu” from RRR.

Best Picture (10/10): Tár.

Production Design (5/5): Florencia Martin and Anthony Carlino, Babylon.

Animated Short Film (4/5): Ice Merchants. I’m sorry that I didn’t get to see An Ostrich Told Me the World Is Fake and I Think I Believe It before making this pick!

Live Action Short Film (2/5): Le Pupille.

Sound (4/5): Mark Weingarten, James H. Mather, Al Nelson, Chris Burdon and Mark Taylor, Top Gun: Maverick.

Visual Effects (4/5): Joe Letteri, Richard Baneham, Eric Saindon and Daniel Barrett, Avatar: The Way of Water.

Adapted Screenplay (5/5): Sarah Polley, Women Talking.

Original Screenplay (5/5): Todd Field, Tár.

2022 Oscar Picks

For the first time in many years, I managed to catch at least one nominated film in every category and all ten Best Picture nominees prior to Oscar night. To commemorate this truly momentous achievement, I have decided to embarrass myself by sharing picks for Sunday’s awards ceremony. Which, needless to say, I am watching despite the Academy’s decision not to include the presentation of eight awards in the broadcast, not because of it. Anyway, these are not predictions: I restricted myself to just movies I’ve seen and don’t claim to have any insight into the voting tendencies of academy members, so I’m not expecting to be right about anything. If you are foolish enough to make wagers based on this post, that is (emphatically) entirely on you, is what I’m saying. Also, you have a gambling problem. Anyway, without further ado, here’s who I’ll be rooting for this weekend!

Actress in a Leading Role: Jessica Chastain – The Eyes of Tammy Faye. But only because Alana Haim wasn’t nominated for Licorice Pizza.

Actor in a Leading Role: Will Smith – King Richard.

Actor in a Supporting Role: Troy Kotsur – CODA.

Actress in a Supporting Role: Jessie Buckley – The Lost Daughter.

Animated Feature Film: The Mitchells vs. the Machines. This was a tough one! But maybe that’s just because I live with a four- and six-year-old and therefore have already seen some of these films eight to ten times? They would probably go with Encanto here, by the way.

Cinematography: Bruno Delbonnel – The Tragedy of Macbeth. Stunning.

Costume Design: Jacqueline West and Robert Morgan – Dune.

Directing: Jane Campion – The Power of the Dog.

Documentary (Feature): Attica.

Documentary (Short Subject): Audible.

Film Editing: Joe Walker – Dune.

International Feature Film: Drive My Car.

Makeup and Hairstyling: Nadia Stacey, Naomi Donne, and Julia Vernon – Cruella.

Music (Original Score): Hans Zimmer – Dune.

Music (Original Song): “Dos Oruguitas” by Lin-Manuel Miranda – Encanto.

Production Design: Patrice Vermette and Zsuzsanna Sipos – Dune.

Short Film (Animated): Robin Robin. I have a soft spot for Christmas movies, and this one is going into our regular rotation.

Short Film (Live Action): The Long Goodbye.

Sound: Tod A. Maitland, Gary Rydstrom, Brian Chumney, Andy Nelson, and Shawn Murphy – West Side Story.

Visual Effects: Paul Lambert, Tristan Myles, Brian Connor and Gerd Nefzer – Dune.

Writing (Adapted Screenplay): Maggie Gyllenhaal – The Lost Daughter.

Writing (Original Screenplay): Kenneth Branagh – Belfast.

Best Picture: Drive My Car.